Court Overturns Feds’ Land Grab Over Phony ‘Jaguar Habitat’

‘It’s not only an abuse of the language—it’s also an abuse of authority…’

Court Sides with Ranchers Over Feds’ Illegal Jaguar Habitat
Coronando National Memorial / IMAGE: Hoosier Tim’s Travel Videos via Youtube

(Michael Barnes, Liberty Headlines) A federal appeals court ruled Wednesday that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service illegally designated thousands of acres of land in New Mexico a protected jaguar habitat, despite only a few jaguar sightings in the state over the past several decades.

The 2014 designation effectively punished ranchers and caused unnecessary fire hazards in the Coronado National Forest.

The court determined the federal agency was “arbitrary and capricious” in how it exercised its vast powers, and that it didn’t even follow its own rules when imposing its authority.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

The government “did not follow its own regulations or provide a rational explanation for failing to do so,” the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals said in a 30-page decision.

The case has taken years to resolve, and the dispute boils down to federal bureaucrats playing word games “to stretch the limits of federal law beyond recognition,” said the Pacific Legal Foundation.

PLF, a nonprofit public-interest law firm representing three agricultural organizations that were affected by the designation: the New Mexico Farm and Livestock Bureau, New Mexico Cattlegrowers’ Association and New Mexico Federal Lands Council.

“This decision helps our clients and it helps Americans everywhere, because it reminds agencies that they must follow the law passed by Congress, and they must follow their own regulations,” said PLF Senior Attorney Christina Martin.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

The Fish and Wildlife Service admitted that jaguars thrive in Central and South American tropical forests, where currently more than 64,000 jaguars live. Legally, this is their “primary” habitat. However, a few non-breeding jaguars have been spotted in small portions of dry areas in New Mexico and Arizona since the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Legally, this constitutes a “marginal,” “secondary” or “peripheral” habitat.

But Fish and Wildlife authorities during the Obama administration took control of thousands of acres of grazing land by arbitrarily deciding that a marginal and secondary habitat can simultaneously be a “critical” and “indispensable” habitat. By melding terms, the agency gave itself the authority to create harsh restrictions and permitting obstacles on ranchers.

“It’s not only an abuse of the language—it’s also an abuse of authority,” PLF said in a statement last year. The statement also said the entire affair was “an apparent effort to appease environmental groups.”

The decision comes after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled unanimously for the legal organization in a similar case in 2019.

According to its website, the Pacific Legal Foundation is dedicated to defending Americans threatened by government overreach and abuse. It currently has active cases in 39 states and Washington D.C.

- Advertisement -


Hunter Biden Had Scheme for SeaWorld Parks in China, Funded by Communist Gov’t

Part of Hunter Biden’s business plans in China included proposals to build SeaWorld theme parks in the country, and to get the Communist government...

WHISTLEBLOWER: Amazon Forces Employees to Confess ‘Unconscious Racial Bias’

Amazon regularly forces its employees to confess their “unconscious racial bias” in meetings with other employees, according to a company whistleblower. About once a month,...

Oklahoma Gov. Signs Law to Protect Drivers Who Hit Rioters Blocking Roadways

Oklahoma's Republican Gov. Kevin Stitt signed a bill on Wednesday to grant protection to drivers who accidentally hit rioters obstructing the roadway. HB 1674 applies...

BLM Hustler Patrisse Cullors Under New Fire for Delinquent ‘Charity’ Disclosures

A 'charity' prison-reform group started by Patrisse Cullors---the race-hustling, Marxist co-founder of Black Lives Matter---has received several warnings from California officials after failing to...

GOP Congressmen Pledge to Refuse Funds from Big Tech

Rep. Ken Buck, R-Colo., announced the Pledge for America on Wednesday, urging GOP lawmakers to refuse campaign donations from Big Tech companies that oppose...

Impeachment Investigators Received Hundreds of Tips About Cuomo’s Conduct

Investigators seeking to determine whether New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo should be impeached said the hotline they set up has received more than 200...

BOONDOGGLE: L.A. Taxpayers’ $1.2B Bond to House Homeless is a BIG Failure

(Christopher F. Rufo, RealClearInvestigations) In 2016 influential political leaders, activists, and media outlets in Los Angeles said they had a simple solution to homelessness: build...

Blue State Govs. Urge Businesses to Speak Out Against Election Laws

(David Bass, Carolina Journal) North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper is leading a nationwide effort in cooperation with Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer to encourage business leaders...

Black Leaders Defend Ga. Election Law Against ‘Outrageous’ Jim Crow Comparisons

Nearly two dozen civil rights leaders and black conservatives defended Georgia’s new election-integrity law and blasted the Leftists comparing it to the Jim Crow...
- Advertisement -