Quantcast

Gifted and Talented School Programs Under Assault

(Headline USA) Communities across the United States are reconsidering their approach to gifted and talented programs in schools, as leftist activists and social justice gadflies try to blame race and gender for low test scores.

A plan announced by New York City’s mayor to phase out elementary school gifted and talented programs in the country’s largest school district — if it proceeds — would be among the most extreme developments yet in a push that extends from Boston to Seattle and that has stoked passions and pain over race, inequality and access to a decent education.

From the start, critics have argued that gifted and talented school programs would produce an educational caste system in U.S. public schools, despite the programs providing an avenue of improved education for all children. 

Many of the programs trace their origins to efforts to stanch “white flight” from public schools, particularly in diversifying urban areas, by providing high-caliber educational programs that could compete with private or parochial schools.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

Increasingly, parents and school boards are grappling with difficult questions over equity, as they discuss how to accommodate the educational aspirations of advanced learners while nurturing other students so they can equally thrive.

The radical Left’s solution: scrap the gifted and talented programs, or let everyone take part regardless of actual academic merit.

It’s a quandary that is driving the debate over whether to expand gifted and talented programs or abolish them altogether.

“I get the burn-it-down and tear-it-down mentality, but what do we replace it with?” asked Marcia Gentry, a professor of education and the director of the Gifted Education Research and Resource Institute at Purdue University.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

Gentry coauthored a study two years ago that used federal data to catalogue racial disparities in gifted and talented programs.

It noted that U.S. schools identified 3.3 million students as gifted and talented but that an additional 3.6 million should have been similarly designated. The additional students missing from those rolls, her study said, were disproportionately black, Latino and Indigenous students.

Nationwide, 8.1% of white and 12.7% of Asian American children in public schools are considered gifted, compared with 4.5% of Hispanic and 3.5% of black students, according to an Associated Press analysis of the most recent federal data.

Gifted and talented programs aim to provide outlets for students who feel intellectually constrained by the instruction offered to their peers. Critics of the push to eliminate them say it punishes high achievers and cuts off a prized opportunity for advancement, particularly for low-income families without access to private enrichment programs.

In Seattle, a schools superintendent who left her job in May sought to do away with the district’s Highly Capable Cohort program, as the district’s gifted and talented program is called, blaming it for causing de facto segregation. In its own recent analysis, Seattle public schools found only 0.9% of Black children had been identified as gifted, compared with 12.6% of its white students.

The school board has approved changes that will do away with eligibility testing and make all grade schoolers automatically eligible for consideration for advanced instruction. In addition to grades, the selection committee will consider testimonials from teachers, family and community members.

The changes don’t go far enough for critics like Rita Green, the education chair of the Seattle Chapter of the NAACP. She has called for more work to build environments that nurture the intellectual development of all the district’s 50,000 schoolchildren.

“We want the program just abolished. Period. The Highly Capable Cohort program is fundamentally flawed, and it’s inherently racist,” Green opined.

Debates over the criteria for admission to advanced courses and elite schools are not new, but the vitriol brought into those discussions has increased from leftist activists.

In Boston, the school committee voted this summer to expand eligibility to its exclusive exam schools and guarantee spots to high-achieving students from poor and disadvantaged neighborhoods, what some might argue is a move to implement racial quotas.

Latino students account for roughly 42% of Boston’s 53,000 public school students — about twice the number as whites — but are underrepresented in advanced courses. By the district’s account, fewer than 20% of the fourth graders invited to participate in advanced work classes were Latino, while 43% of those invited were white.

Many children are overlooked because of language and cultural barriers, said Iván Espinoza-Madrigal, the executive director of Boston’s Lawyers for Civil Rights. Alleged subconscious bias among teachers who nominate students for the program also play a role, he said.

Elsewhere, the renowned Lowell High School in San Francisco in February scrapped admissions exams in favor of a lottery system. In Fairfax County, Virginia, parents recently lost a legal bid to undo their school district’s decision to do away with testing for admissions to a campus catering to high achievers in science and technology.

Most gifted and talented programs have relied on tests to determine eligibility, with some families paying for tutoring and programs to boost scores and increase their children’s academic performance to earn a spot.

Controversy over admissions into advanced education programs has simmered in other cities, including Los Angeles and Chicago. But nowhere has the debate been as intense as in New York, where Mayor Bill de Blasio said last month that he would begin to dismantle the program in elementary schools, calling it “exclusive and exclusionary.”

Some parents, including Rose Zhu, have called on the city to expand the program, not do away with it. She joined dozens of other parents outside the city’s Department of Education building this month to protest de Blasio’s proposal, bringing along her 21-month-old daughter, who Zhu hopes will follow two older siblings into the city’s gifted and talented program.

“I live in Queens, and our traditional schools in our districts aren’t really good,” she said. “So the G and T program is the best school I can put them in.”

De Blasio’s likely successor, fellow Democrat Eric Adams, has said he does not support eliminating the program, which would put him at odds with some of his black constituents. Adams himself is black.

One such constituent, Zakiyah Ansari, the New York City director for the Alliance for Quality Education, wants Adams to follow through with de Blasio’s pledge.

“We believe every child is a gifted child, every child is a talented child,” Ansari said.

But Gentry, the director of the Gifted Education Research and Resource Institute, agreed that it was time for “a revolution to fix the problem that’s been long standing in terms of equity” in access to gifted and talented instruction.

She urged parents and school administrators to do the hard work of finding a compromise.

“I worry that the easy solution is to stop doing it,” she said. “I know the inequities exist. But the thing is, there’s a huge distinction between overhauling or eliminating.”

Adapted from reporting by the Associated Press.

Copyright 2022. No part of this site may be reproduced in whole or in part in any manner without the permission of the copyright owner. To inquire about licensing content, use the contact form at https://headlineusa.com/advertising.
- Advertisement -

TRENDING NOW

Jan. 6 Inquisition Requests Interview with Ivanka Trump

(Headline USA) The House committee investigating the U.S. Capitol protests is asking Ivanka Trump, daughter of former President Donald Trump, to voluntarily cooperate with...

California Bill Would Create Safe Consumption Sites for Drug Use

(Madison Hirneisen, The Center Square) To confront an increase in opioid-related overdose deaths in California, one state legislator is working to advance a bill...

NANNY STATE: USC Frat Parties Must Now Have Security Guard Present

(Headline USA) Most fraternities at the University of Southern California will be allowed to start having parties again in March if security guards are...

US Drops Case Against MIT Professor Accused of Ties to China

(Headline USA) The Justice Department dropped its case Thursday against a Massachusetts Institute of Technology professor accused of concealing ties to the Chinese government,...

Judges Didn’t Consider ‘Wisdom’ of Deporting Novak Djokovic

(Headline USA) Three Australian Federal Court judges on Thursday revealed their reasons for backing a government order to deport tennis star Novak Djokovic, explaining...

Biden’s Big Lie about Midterm’s Validity Undergoes Frantic Spin Operation

(Jacob Bruns, Headline USA) White House press secretary Jen Psaki worked her wiles once more, this time covering for President Joe Biden's most recent gaffe...

WATCH: Los Angeles School Appears to Rope Off Unvaxxed Students from Classmates

(Jacob Bruns, Headline USA) School officials in Los Angeles allegedly roped off group of unvaxxed students from their classmates, giving a twisted, Orwellian overtone...

NBC’s Resident Biden Shill Thinks Train-Wreck Press Conference Went Swimmingly

NBC News correspondent Yamiche Alcindor took to Twitter to praise President Biden for his performance in a press conference Wednesday that NBC itself described...

N. Korea May Resume Nuclear, ICBM Tests Suspended During Trump Détente

(Headline USA) Accusing the United States of hostility and threats, North Korea on Thursday said it will consider restarting “all temporally-suspended activities” it had...
- Advertisement -