Quantcast

Appeals Court: Elizabeth Warren Has Immunity from Covington Catholic Defamation Suit

Tweets 'were calculated to serve the interests of defendants’ constituents...'

The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in a decision Thursday that two Democratic Congresswomen cannot be prosecuted for defamation against the Covington Catholic teens because of qualified immunity, Bloomberg Law reported.

The young men sued Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and Rep. Deb. Haaland, D-N.M., for defamation over tweets that the two politicians sent.

“Omaha elder and Vietnam War veteran Nathan Phillips endured hateful taunts with dignity and strength, then urged us all to do better. Listen to his words,” Warren said in a false representation of the encounter.

“The students’ display of blatant hate, disrespect, and intolerance is a signal of how common decency has decayed under this administration. Heartbreaking,” Haaland wrote in a tweet.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

Judge Eric L. Clay authored the opinion, which Judges Helene N. White and Chad A. Readler agreed to.

The judges found that the Federal Tort Claims Act protects legislators from lawsuits because it considers them to be federal employees.

Clay wrote that Warren and Haaland’s false tweets were services to their constituents.

The tweets “were calculated to serve the interests of defendants’ constituents (i.e., employers) by informing them of defendants’ views regarding a topical issue and related legislation,” Clay wrote.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

It’s unclear how the tweets related to public policy or legislation.

“Congressmembers routinely broadcast their views on pending legislation and related current events through press releases, televised speeches, interviews, and, as in the present case, through social media postings,” Clay wrote.

He describe the tweets as “errands” for constituents that are roughly equivalent to “preparing so-called ‘news letters’ to constituents, news releases, and speeches delivered outside the Congress.”

- Advertisement -

TRENDING NOW

Biden Admin Admits to Secretly Smuggling Immigrant Kids into NY, Other States

President Joe Biden's administration was forced to admit it has been smuggling illegal immigrant minors into New York by plane at night, following a...

Sheriffs Reject Lightfoot’s Call for Backup as Chicago Police Quit over Vax Mandate

Two Illinois sheriffs said they would not send their deputies to fill in Chicago’s staffing shortages as Democrat Mayor Lori Lightfoot tries to force...

Illegal Immigration Arrests Highest They’ve Been Since 1986

Under the Biden administration, US Border Patrol arrests reached the highest levels this past year since 1986, according to recently released data from US...

McAuliffe Has Mid-Interview Meltdown, Tells Reporter to Ask ‘Better Questions’

With his once dominant lead in rapid decline against a political newcomer, former Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe---also the state's current Democratic gubernatorial candidate---stormed out...

CRAPO: Dems Attempting Bait-and-Switch w/ ‘Revised’ IRS Spying Scheme

Sen. Mike Crapo, R-Idaho blasted a revised Democrat proposal that would allow the IRS to track bank accounts of virtually every American by establishing...

Dems Block Bill to Protect Vax Holdouts from Losing Social Security, Gov’t Benefits

Democrats in the Senate this week blocked a bill by Sen. Rick Scott, R-Fla., that would have prevented the government from mandating vaccines for...

Texas Gov. Abbott Splits w/ Conservatives over Property Tax Reform

(Bethany Blankley, The Center Square) After the third special legislative session ended, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott issued a statement praising the accomplishments of the...

Poll Gives Mixed Report on NY Gov. Hochul’s Early Favorability, Re-Election Prospects

(Steve Bittenbender, The Center Square) A new Siena College poll that came out Tuesday shows mostly good news for New York Gov. Kathy Hochul. However,...

NJ Launches Program to Give Tax Dollars to Illegals

(T.A. DeFeo, The Center Square) New Jersey taxpayers are on the hook for $40 million in one-time payments for undocumented people living in the...
- Advertisement -