COMMENT: Congress Should Investigate ‘Gain-of-Function’ Research

(Bill King, RealClear Wire) I fear that the investigations Republicans have promised in the House next year will be little more than another round of toxic partisan gamesmanship. But there is one investigation Congress should undertake, and that is into so-called “gain-of-function” research.

Before the pandemic, I suspect that most of you, like me, had never heard of gain-of-function research. What we learned during the pandemic is that scientists around the world routinely tinker with the genome of viruses to see how the induced changes will affect replication of the virus (contagiousness) and the effects it has on its host (lethality). Such research has apparently been going on for decades and is routinely funded by governments, including ours.

Within weeks of the COVID-19 virus emerging in China near the Wuhan Institute of Virology, many began to question whether the virus had been created by gain-of-function research and somehow escaped from WIV’s labs.

Recently analyzed Chinese documents from early in the pandemic seem to suggest the virus might have come from WIV. To many, the proposition that the novel coronavirus just happened to naturally occur a few hundred yards from the WIV facility seemed too much of a coincidence.

But in February 2020, barely three months after the virus’s genome had been sequenced, 27 scientists signed a statement in the medical journal The Lancet, unequivocally declaring that the virus had occurred naturally and that any suggestion to the contrary was quackery and a conspiracy theory. Their statement quickly became the accepted orthodoxy for much of the world’s scientific community and virtually all the mainstream media.

As time wore on, circumstances regarding the origin of that statement came under scrutiny. In a 2021 Vanity Fair article, investigative journalist Katherine Eban revealed that the statement was organized by a scientist named Peter Daszak. That statement concluded with a declaration from the scientists who signed it that “we have no competing interests.”

However, Eban reported in a follow-up article that Daszak was the director of EcoHealth Alliance, which in 2014 had received a $3.7 million grant from the NIH for gain-of-function research and made a sub-grant for $600,000—to the WIV.

I wrote to the email address reserved for the statement in the Lancet post, posing a number of questions about the circumstances around the creation of the letter and the “competing interests” statement. I also reached out to two of the scientists who signed the letter asking for an interview regarding the statement. I received no responses.

Questions about gain-of-function research pre-date COVID. In fact, there has been a robust debate over the potential risks and benefits that dates to, at least, 2011.

In 2014, a group of 300 prominent scientists, led by Harvard’s highly regarded epidemiologist Marc Lipsitch, signed a statement raising alarms about risks associated with gain-of-function research.

The academic controversy caused the Obama administration to issue a moratorium on gain-of-function research, but it included a general exception for studies “urgently necessary to protect the public health or national security.”

According to Eban’s reporting, the exception quickly became a glaring loophole that essentially rendered the rule useless: the controversial research mostly continued unabated.

The Trump administration scrapped the moratorium in favor of a complex review process. But that process was mostly conducted outside of the public’s view or even significant peer review, leaving many of the critics, including Lipsitch, still wary.

The debate over the origins of COVID still rages today and unfortunately has become politicized, with Democrats and Republicans generally lining up behind the natural and lab-leak theories, respectively.

In August 2021, the National Intelligence Council issued an unclassified report in response to an order from President Biden to review the origin of the virus. The report stated that the intelligence community had not been able to reach a conclusion and that the origin would likely never be known without more cooperation from the Chinese government. Of course, the more time that passes the less likely it is that the mystery will ever be solved.

While we would all like to know how the pandemic started, the mere fact that it might have originated from gain-of-function research gone awry makes it imperative to conduct a detailed investigation of the risks and potential benefits of this kind of research.

Of all the things we regulate, surely tinkering with viruses to make them more contagious and more lethal should be right at the top of the list. Congress needs to pass laws closely regulating what Rutgers professor Richard Ebright described to Katherine Eban as “looking for a gas leak with a lighted match” and not leave this up to executive orders.

Congress should also investigate what appears to have been a coordinated attempt to squelch any inquiry into the legitimate questions over COVID’s origins in the early days of the pandemic.

For example, the signers of the Lancet statement should be subpoenaed and questioned about what was almost certainly a false certification of “no competing interests” by at least one of the signers. (The criticism regarding potential conflicts of interest is not just coming from the right: The uber-progressive Columbia professor Jeffrey Sachs disbanded a group he had established to study the origins of COVID, citing conflicts of interest. Interestingly, Daszak was part of the group Sachs disbanded.)

I don’t know whether House Republicans can conduct such hearings without turning them into a carnival sideshow. But hopefully they will rise above partisan instincts and deliver much-needed answers for the American people.

Winter Storm Death Toll Climbs as Biden Basks in Caribbean

(Headline USA) As President Joe Biden luxuriated on a posh Caribbean vacation, roads reopened Thursday in storm-besieged Buffalo, N.Y. Meanwhile, authorities continued searching for people who may have died or been stuck and suffering after last week’s blizzard.

The driving ban in New York’s second-most-populous city was lifted just after midnight Thursday, Mayor Byron Brown announced.

At least 40 deaths in western New York, most of them in Buffalo, have been reported from the blizzard that raged across much of the country, with Buffalo in its crosshairs on Friday and Saturday.

“Significant progress has been made” on snow removal, Brown said at a news conference late Wednesday. Suburban roads, major highways and Buffalo Niagara International Airport had already reopened.

As the storm damage raged, so did Twitter, with Biden receiving criticism on multiple fronts for sunning on the beach while people died in the streets from the bitter cold.

The National Guard was going door-to-door in Buffalo to check on people who lost power, and authorities faced the possibility of finding more victims as snow melted amid increasingly mild weather. Buffalo police and officers from other law enforcement agencies also searched for victims, sometimes using officers’ personal snowmobiles, trucks and other equipment.

Some victims have yet to be identified, Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz said at a storm briefing Thursday.

“There are families in this community who still have not been able to identify where a loved one is, they’re missing,” he said.

With the death toll already surpassing that of the area’s notorious Blizzard of 1977 and rising daily, local officials faced questions about the response to last week’s storm. They insisted that they prepared but the weather was extraordinary, even for a region prone to powerful winter storms.

“The city did everything that it could under historic blizzard conditions,” the mayor said Wednesday.

Officials are now closely watching a forecast that calls for some rain later in the week as snow melts in temperatures approaching or topping 50 degrees, leaving the potential for another wave of disaster due to flooding.

The National Weather Service forecast that any flooding would be minor, but state and local officials said they were preparing nonetheless.

Gov. Kathy Hochul said the state was ready to deploy nearly 800,000 sandbags and more than 300 pumps and generators for flooding response efforts if needed.

During his briefing, Poloncarz apologized for publicly criticizing the city of Buffalo’s snow removal efforts as too slow, even “embarrassing,” a day earlier.

“We’ve been dealing with much, including the unfolding issues associated with the deaths, the identification of bodies, individuals who have not yet been identified, and new deaths that are coming in that are absolutely heartbreaking,” said Poloncarz, adding that he was trying to contact Brown to make amends. “I basically lost my focus.”

Brown had rebuffed Poloncarz’s complaints, saying Wednesday that the city had been “working diligently, working around the clock” to clear snow and strove to work cooperatively with others in government and the community.

Brown, Poloncarz and Hochul all are Democrats.

A company that estimates damage from natural disasters said insured losses from the winter storm would be $5.4 billion across 42 states. Karen Clark & Co. said New York, Texas, Georgia, Tennessee and North Carolina sustained the most storm damage, with freezing temperatures, which can result in infrastructure disruptions and burst pipes, accounting for the vast majority of the loss.

Adapted from reporting by the Associated Press

Leftists Peddle Fake News about Greta Thunberg Aiding Arrest of Andrew Tate

(Mark Pellin, Headline USA) The mainstream media and its leftist collaborators on social media gleefully promoted and parroted a bogus narrative that climate cult idol Greta Thunberg’s cunning was responsible for the arrest of Andrew Tate.

The self-proclaimed misogynist, former kickboxing champion and social media influencer was taken into police custody Thursday in Romania on suspicion of rape, human trafficking and organized crime offenses.

Tate’s arrest came after he had sent a blistering message to Thunberg that contained the image of a pizza box, which Thunberg acolytes claimed led police to Tate’s location after being baited by the climate activist hero.

“yes, please do enlighten me. email me at [email protected],” Thunberg mocked in a response to a Tate post.

Tate fired back with a rant that went viral.

The Left erupted in praise of Thunberg for using her wits to help apprehend an enemy of their radical agenda.

“Not only did Greta Thunberg destroy Andrew Tate with her tweet, she made him so angry he inadvertently tipped off Romanian authorities of his presence in Romania with his lame comeback video,” crowed Alejandra Caraballo, activist writer for Wired and Slate, who proclaimed, “Greta is an absolute legend.”

Other leftists joined in the praise, which turned out to be wholly undeserved and the product of a fake news narrative.

“This is a social media goldmine. Bad dick head gets into fight with courageous teen climate hero, accidentally reveals location, ends up in prison,” explained activist writer Ben Dreyfuss. “I know it’s a compelling story because when I read it in the Daily Beast, I tweeted it.”

The only problem being that the story was totally bogus, fabricated by tweaking original reporting to fit a preconceived leftist narrative.

Dreyfuss dismissed any “conspiracy behind it,” regarding how and why the fake news painting Thunberg as hero was aggressively promoted, but conceded the story “is total bullshit.”

“All of the places ‘reporting’ it are just aggregating speculation that began with this twitter account jumping to a conclusion based on 1 line in a Romanian report,” Dreyfuss wrote.

“Unless Google is missing some Romanian language nuance, this sentence does not say that the police were tipped off by a social media post to his whereabouts, let alone that it was by his video with Greta Thunberg,” he informed. “It says they confirmed it in multiple ways at least some of which involved social media.”

Not that it mattered to confirmed climate alarmists eager to push their agenda and bogus narrative, including the sanctimonious cult leader herself.

CDC Monitoring School Teachers’ Levels of ‘LGBT Inclusivity’

(Dmytro “Henry” Aleksandrov, Headline USA) In yet another example of egregious government overreach to help peddle a far-leftist agenda, the Biden regime’s Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has started monitoring school teachers’ levels of acceptance of sexual deviancy in schools while pushing advocacy for LGBT cult clubs.

To do that, CDC released a so-called “assessment tool” handbook that instructs educators how to check for their sins of stepping away from the approved radical LGBT party line, according to the Post Millennial. If educators find themselves falling short or not as committed to the cause as a typical leftist should be, the handbook urges them to “commit to change”.

“School administrators: Our LGBTQ inclusivity self-assessment tool can help you quickly gauge inclusivity at your school. See your score today and learn ways to increase inclusivity,” CDC tweeted.

The organization also included a link to the 32-page handbook that has three categories. The “highly inclusive” teachers are called “awesome allies” for their total acceptance of sexual deviancy. The “moderately inclusive” teachers are just not there yet. The “minimally inclusive” teachers, though, do not go along with the leftist agenda and, therefore, need to “commit to change.”

To follow the party line and achieve an “ally” score, a teacher must bend the knee and agree with statements like “My classroom or learning space includes visual labels (e.g., rainbow flags, pink triangles, unisex bathroom signs) marking it as a safe space for LGBTQ students.”

The handbook also verifies if teachers use so-called “gender-neutral” terms like “partner” instead of “boyfriend” or “girlfriend” when it comes to describing romantic relationships, reported Breitbart.

Educators are also expected to use preferred names and pronouns of boys and girls pretending to be the opposite sex and terms like “a body with a penis” or “a body with a vagina” instead of “male” or “female” during sexual education which eliminates the whole point of said education because of erasure of difference between sexes.

Along with the instructional tips, the handbook also encourages letting trans students use bathrooms of their choice and decorating classrooms with LGBT flags, posters and other activist props.

CDC has been issuing these self-assessment handbooks since Oct. 2020.

According to Parents Defending Education founder and president Nicole Neily, this is just another attempt of leftists to bully a few people in the field of education whose beliefs are not aligned with the woke mob.

“The CDC’s imprimatur on this ‘self-assessment tool’ — and the inclusion of numerous links to resources and activist organizations — amounts to little more than bullying teachers, administrators and school health professionals who might have reservations about ‘affirmation’ and ‘inclusion’ efforts in schools,” she said.

Biden Blunder Likely to Trigger China Sabotage at Air Force Base

(Joshua Paladino, Headline USA) President Joe Biden approved a Chinese company’s purchase of 370 acres of land only 12 miles away from the Grand Forks Air Force Base in North Dakota, a decision that critics and security experts said could lead to “sabotage of operations.”

With Fufeng USA’s purchase of a $700 million corn milling plant in Grand Forks, North Dakota, the Chinese military will be able to intercept American military communications and to jam signals, the Gatestone Institute reported.

Fufeng USA operates under a Chinese company based in Shandong province, China.

The Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States, which decides when the federal government may block land sales to foreign nations, found that the property was not a “covered transaction.”

The CFIUS said Section 721 of the Defense Production Act of 1950 did not give them the authority to intervene in the transaction.

Alan Tonelson, a researcher at the Business and Industry Council Educational Foundation, said the committee “did not need more than five minutes to determine that it did not have the authority to stop the sale.”

The CFIUS could not act because Congress failed to include the Grand Forks Air Force Base Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act of 2018 in its list of “specific airports, maritime ports, or military installations.”

“Grand Forks Air Force Base did not make the cut,” Tonelson said. “The decision of the Congressional authors of the recent CFIUS reform to permit any foreign purchase of any land near any U.S. military installation was a clear case of legislative malpractice.”

Fufeng USA cannot ignore the Chinese Communist Party’s request to spy on American military installations. Under Articles 7 and 14 of China’s National Intelligence Law of 2017, all Chinese companies must comply with orders to spy on foreign militaries.

“The worst-case scenario involves active sabotage of operations at the Grand Forks facility,” military expert Brandon Weichert points out.

“Should the U.S. and China end up in a shooting war over, say, Taiwan, Fufeng’s property near the Air Force base could be used to send malicious signals to jam passing satellites or disrupt the operation of drones. We have made ourselves vulnerable on our own territory,” he said.

Libs of TiKTok Creator Gives Massive ‘Middle Finger’ to Leftists

(Dmytro “Henry” Aleksandrov, Headline USA) Chaya Raichik, creator of the massively popular and influential Libs of TikTok account, explained this week why she decided to publicly reveal her face, after remaining anonymous under constant threats from the compassionate Left’s doxxing and vile harassment campaigns.

Since she started her social media account, Raichik has been hated by leftists, even though the only “transgression” she’s committed has been re-posting and sharing the insanity and dangerous delusions being peddled by the far-Left.

After alleged journalist Taylor Lorenz doxxed Raichik, the intimidation and harassment, including multiple death threats, escalated and she remained anonymous, even as the popularity and reach of Libs of TiTok surged. Raichick decided to go public this week during a blockbuster interview with Tucker Carlson.

In Raichik’s Substack update, she wrote that when her account first started getting attention, she was “relieved” to be anonymous.

“… the Left was brazen with their threats of violence against people they disagree with, including me.”

Raichik said she decided to become a public figure because she wanted to protect children from the leftist agenda.

“Staying behind a screen and restricted to 240 characters on Twitter just isn’t enough anymore to counteract the rampant issues with the Left’s agenda in America,” she wrote. “It’s not an easy thing to reveal your face to millions of people, especially considering the number of death threats I receive.”

Raichik said that revealing her face was the equivalent of “flipping a bird” to leftists, including journalists, who mocked her for being afraid.

“I’m not hiding, and I’m not scared of whatever they try to throw at me to stop me from exposing them,” Raichik wrote.

She said she will be “more effective out in the open, teaching others how they can make a difference in this cultural war.” Raichik said she plans to continue fighting for the kids by going against the “deep, dark, and systemic … targeting of our children.”

In a previous interview with the Daily Wire, Raichik said that she never wanted Libs of TikTok to go viral.

“People think that I started this and I had this whole plan and I wanted to harass people on the Left,” she said. “[They think] I had this whole agenda… I was just having fun.”

However, while she was searching for funny clips of leftists spewing nonsense, she realized that their rhetoric may destroy this country if people aren’t going to fight back.

She said that the reason leftists hate her is that she shows them their true colors.

“You’re holding up a mirror,” she said. “I think they feel threatened.”

Climate Cult Scare Tactics Target Fast Food Menus

(Joshua Paladino, Headline USA) Climate alarmists and activists are pushing for new regulations after a study purported to find that putting climate impact warnings on fast food menus caused fewer people to buy beef products and more people to buy salads, chicken, and fish.

Researchers put the “low climate impact” and “high climate impact” warning labels in a trial with 5,000 participants, and they published these results in JAMA Network Open.

The negative label had a greater impact on choices than the positive label when compared to a control group. The high climate impact label caused 25% fewer customers to buy beef, while the low climate impact label only caused 10% more customers to buy salads.

“We found that labelling red meat items with negatively framed, red high–climate impact labels was more effective at increasing sustainable selections than labelling non–red meat items with positively framed, green low–climate impact labels,’ said Julia Wolfson, a professor at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health who authored the study.

The study showed that climate change alarmists can get the best results by pushing guilt and fear rather than by promoting so-called sustainable products.

The low-climate impact label stated that the “item is environmentally sustainable. It has low greenhouse gas emissions and a low contribution to climate change.’

The researchers even convinced participants that the low-climate impact options, like salad and chicken, were better options for their health, even though all fast food items contain toxic ingredients, like inflammation-causing seed oils, and non-food additives, fillers and flavor stimulants.

The study relied on the idea that methane from beef production will harm the planet, while soy and corn monocropping will heal the planet or at least slow climate change.

But the researchers ignored the fact that soy and corn products deplete the top soil, lack essential nutrients, and cause obesity and heart disease, while animal husbandry regenerates the top soil and creates a nutrient-dense product.

FBI’s No. 1 Russia-Hoaxer, Peter Strzok, Offers Oddball Theory about George Santos

(Jacob Bruns, Headline USA) In a lengthy Twitter thread, Russia-hoax architect and disgraced FBI agent Peter Strzok theorized that Republican congressman-elect George Santos was a Putin plant.

“While everyone’s looking at George Devolder–Santos, it’s worth looking at him—especially his wealth and fundraising questions—from a counterintelligence perspective,” Strzok wrote, before adding that Santos may have had a vague connection to a Russian oligarch.

“From the ‘many times during [his] career’ he claims to have visited Moscow, to the over $56,000 he received from Andrew Intrater, a cousin and money manager for sanctioned Russian oligarch Viktor Vekselberg” he added.

Strzok also dug up some of the Republican candidate’s past statements concerning the Russia–Ukraine conflict, wherein Santos simply noted that Ukraine is a “totalitarian regime” and therefore is “not a great bastion of freedom.”

The accusations follow reports that Santos made a number of dishonest statments on the campaign trail about his background.

They were subsequently exposed by left-wing outlets like the New York Times after Santos made GOP history as an LGBT candidate and succeeded in flipping a traditionally blue district of New York.

Amid calls on the Left for Santos to resign, many Republicans have stood behind him, pointing out the troublesome truthiness that Democrat candidates have demonstrated, up to and including President Joe Biden.

Others, like newly-red-pilled independent Tulsi Gabbard, who left the Democrats because of their moral turpitude, were particularly brutal in criticizing his lack of “integrity.”

“Do you have no shame?” Gabbard asked him while guest-hosting for Fox News’s Tucker Carlson.

Regardless, of their opinions about the new congressman, all could agree that Strzok was hardly the right messenger to lead the criticism of Santos.

“[O]f course here we have a former FBI agent who got fired from the agency insinuating he’s a Kremlin spy because he’s traveled to Moscow,” wrote red-pilled pundit Glenn Greenwald. “Democratic Party discourse is McCarthyism in its purest form.”

Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., also laughed at the fact that Strzok could not help himself.

“Oh look one of the chief liars formerly from the liars division at the FBI is attacking George Santos and trying to convince everyone George is involved in Russian collusion,” she tweeted. “Peter can’t you use your elite minded education and come up with a new lie? Russia lies are so 2016.”

Cher Projects Her Own Vaccine Hesitancy, Blames Flu on Anti-Vaxxers

(Jacob Bruns, Headline USA) Faded pop star Cher recently blamed anti-vaxxers for her having gotten the flu, insisting that their “propaganda” had disuaded her from getting a preventative flu shot.

“Was going to get Flu Shot, but Hesitated, Cause of Antivaxers PROPAGANDA,” she claimed in a Dec. 17 tweet.

“If u don’t Want Vaccination, keep it to your Self. WTF IS WRONG WITH THESE PPL,” she ranted.

The 76-year-old diva has been known for espousing her radical leftist views on social media. That sometimes includes the spread of misinformation, as when she claimed Africa was a country and that Black Lives Matter was a suffrage movement.

In fact, some might argue that the “I Got You, Babe” singer is herself responsible for foisting anti-vaxx rhetoric onto her 4 million followers.

Echoing the concerns of many vaccine skeptics, she tweeted in August 2020 that she would refuse to take the experimental jabs on Trump’s watch because they had not been fully field-tested.

“THERE IS NO FKNG WAY IM TAKING A VACCINE THAT TRUMP WONT LET GO THROUGH THE THIRD & MOST IMPORTANT SAFETY TRIAL,” she wrote in all caps. “WINNING AT ANY COST IS ALL HE CARES ABOUT.”

Immediately after the Nov. 3 election was secured for Democrat Joe Biden, vaccine companies Pfizer and Moderna both announced they were ready to begin rolling out their mRNA-altering serums, leading many on the Left to pivot sharply in favor of mass and compulsory vaccinations.

In a two-year clinical trial of roughly 263 million Americans, the vaccines have since shown mixed results, with many unexplained deaths and serious illnesses appearing to be linked to them—potentially making the cure more deadly than the disease in low-risk populations like those under 65 with no mitigating factors.

As for Cher, she likely would have been glad to turn back time on her initial vaccine hesitancy. A mere 10 months later, not only was she singing the praises of the vaccines but told MSNBC’s Nicolle Wallace that she was embarking on a bus tour to help underserved communities get vaxxed.

The one-time wife of the late U.S. congressman Sony Bono, R-Calif., also reportedly sparked up a new romance with—and perhaps even engagement to—36-year-old Alexander Edwards.

Her decision to settle down with a man 40 years her junior may come as a surprise to some—not because of the age gap but because it is likely to derail her previously stated plans for interstellar space travel.

In June 2015, shortly after Donald Trump announced his candidacy, Cher led the way among a litany of leftist celebs who threatened to repatriate if Trump were to win, thereby depriving those left behind of a national treasure.

Headline USA’s Ben Sellers contributed to this report.

Drag Queen Groomers Defy DeSantis, Parents w/ Raunchy Christmas Show

(Mark Pellin, Headline USA) Drag queens performed a filth-filled, sexually explicit show with kids in attendance on Wednesday in Florida, after Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis warned that the child abuse grooming production, and the venue where the show took place, could face criminal investigation and prosecution.

“The show displayed drag queens and others dancing sensually,” reported Florida Voice, which recorded the program.

“For example, one performance included ‘Screwdolph the red-nippled reindeer’ with breasts that lit up red: ‘Screwdolph with your nipples so bright, won’t you guide my sleigh tonight,’ was sung during the performance,” the Voice reported.

“During one performance, one of the drag queens said ‘just throw your wiener on me,’ making a sexual joke to the other drag queen.”

In response to complaints and concerns about the show, which was promoted as “all ages” and family-friendly, Florida’s Department of Business & Professional Regulation issued a warning surrounding sexually explicit drag shows:

The Department has reason to believe that this drag show is of a sexual nature, involving the exposure or exhibition of sexual organs, simulated sexual activity, and/or the sexualization of children’s stories. The Department has also become aware that drag shows by Drag Fans have been marketed to and attended by minors, including young children.

Sexually explicit drag show performances constitute public nuisances, lewd activity, and disorderly conduct when minors are in attendance.

In short, if you allow children to attend the Drag Fans drag show at your facility, you are putting your license in jeopardy.

To avoid action being taken against your license, it is your obligation to ensure that minors are prohibited from attending the Drag Fans drag show.

If minors are allowed to attend this drag show, the Department will take any and all actions available to ensure that you do not pose a threat to minors in the future.

The warning was ignored, as children were present for Wednesday’s show.

Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody told Fox News that the show and the venue should both be held accountable.

“In addition to being the AG, I am also a mom ever-vigilant about protecting my child,” Moody said.

“When folks are complaining, when there’s an allegation that children are being exposed to inappropriate material, whether that’s with a parent or not, I can tell you as a judge and a former prosecutor, I saw all the time parents that against laws exposed children to explicit sexually suggestive material,” she said.

“That doesn’t exempt anyone, a parent or a business, from liability for such behavior. This governor and our executive branch will not sit back while children or anyone else is harmed.”