Quantcast

Trump Helps GOP Sens. Stall Renewal of USA Freedom Act, Derail FBI’s Domestic Spying

‘While the House tells us to trust government to police itself, I prefer instead to trust the Founders’ guidance in the Bill of Rights…’

(Ben Sellers, Liberty Headlines) At the behest of two libertarian-leaning GOP senators, President Donald Trump said he would consider vetoing a bill that would renew the authority of the federal investigators to legally spy on U.S. citizens—and even rival presidential campaigns.

The lingering questions and opposition made it likely that the bill would not meet its March 15 sunset deadline, presumably leaving intelligence agencies without some of the domestic surveillance protections that they have ostensibly used in the war against terrorism and other threats to U.S. security.

While Republicans have been largely unified in staving off congressional Democrats’ attacks, they have been at loggerheads over the passage of the USA Freedom Reauthorization Act, a post-Sept.-11 update to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act that is set to expire on Sunday.

Powerful Senate GOP leaders such as Majority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, Judiciary Chair Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and Intelligence Chair Richard Burr of North Carolina have supported the bill’s renewal, despite major concerns raised by a report from the Justice Department inspector general last December.

The House passed its version of the bill on Wednesday, reported The Hill, with a 278-136 vote garnering bipartisan support after extensive negotiations involving House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif.

The bill was touted by the likes of Reps. Jerrold Nadler of New York and Adam Schiff of California as an acceptable “compromise.”

But critics said the calls from Attorney General William Barr for a “clean renewal”—or even a compromise that doesn’t offer substantive reforms—carried echoes of the demands from the same corrupt intelligence leaders who abused it to begin with.

Justice Deparment Let Mueller Be Special Counsel Despite 'Conflict of Interest'
Robert Mueller, James Comey and Barack Obama / IMAGE: The Obama White House via Youtube

Brett Tolman, a former U.S. attorney who also worked as counsel for the Senate Judiciary Committee, argued in a recent op-ed for the Washington Examiner that former FBI directors Robert Mueller and James Comey (then deputy attorney general) had made similar cases during a 2005 renewal.

Although privacy advocates secured a unanimous Senate vote for additional safeguards and accountability, the 2005 legislation failed to gain traction in the House, where “Comey’s and Mueller’s efforts … prevailed in preventing meaningful reforms,” Tolman said.

“I was one of very few in the room when Comey represented that U.S. citizens need not worry about being surveilled and that internal safeguards were sufficient,” Tolman continued. “Mueller would take a similar position, reassuring us that privacy concerns were overstated, and a ‘clean’ reauthorization was vital.

Among those who now remain firmly opposed to the current renewal are key members of the House Freedom Caucus, as well as Sens. Mike Lee of Utah and Rand Paul of Kentucky, all of whom say respecting citizens’ privacy is paramount.

Lee, along with Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., had sought to promote a strong reform bill, but without the support of GOP leadership, that effort seemed unlikely to go far.

On Wednesday, Lee assured concerned citizens that “there are a lot of procedural tools at our disposal” which could be used to slow the House bill’s progress before Sunday’s deadline.

He sought to offer several amendments to the bill during a House floor debate on Thursday but was repeatedly shut down by Burr, noted FreedomWorks in a statement supporting Lee’s effort.

“Sen. Lee made an amazing, impassioned case for defending Americans’ Fourth Amendment rights against intrusive government surveillance authorities that have often been abused,” said the statement.

Rand Paul and Mike Lee / IMAGE: CSPAN via Youtube

“All he asked for was the ability to have an actual debate to amend a bill that falls woefully short of upholding those rights,” it continued. “In contrast, not only did Sen. Burr block Sen. Lee’s every attempt to secure votes on common-sense, bi-partisan amendments to the FISA reauthorization, he willfully mischaracterized Lee’s own positions and falsely accused him of holding the bill ‘hostage’.”

FreedomWorks said that the lawmakers themselves may be misreading what the provisions of the House bill actually say—effectively arguing, as House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., notoriously said of Obamacare that Congress has to pass it to know what’s in it.

“Sen. Burr further made the dangerous claim that if the expiring provisions of FISA sunset this weekend as scheduled, the executive branch would be able to continue their surveillance activities unabated,” said FreedomWorks. “This raises serious new questions about how these laws are being interpreted that lawmakers must follow-up on as soon as possible.”

However, Trump’s threat of a veto two days before the sunset—as Congress eyes a spring recess and the threat of the coronavirus leaving some members in quarantine—presents yet another hurdle to the bill’s timely passage.

As the Senate appeared set to adjourn without passage, Paul issued a statement on Friday reaffirming his position.

“As President Trump has repeatedly stated, we should not reauthorize these expiring surveillance powers without real reform,” said the statement.

“After all we have learned about how government has abused its authority, including spying on President Trump’s 2016 campaign, neither a clean extension nor the window dressing offered by the U.S. House, which will not stop future abuses, are acceptable,” he continued. “While the House tells us to trust government to police itself, I prefer instead to trust the Founders’ guidance in the Bill of Rights.”

TRENDING NOW

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg Dead at 87; Civilization-Defining Nomination Battle Ahead

(Associated Press) Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the court's second female justice, died Friday at her home in Washington. She was 87. Ginsburg died...

In Wake of Riots, Trump Gains Surprise Ground in Solid-Blue Minnesota

(Headline USA) A solidly blue state for the past half century, Minnesota became an unquestioned presidential battleground on Friday as President Donald Trump and...

Biden Draws Crowd of 200 on Campaign Trail, Largest Real Audience Since March

Democrat presidential hopeful Joe Biden desperately tried to salvage the loss of another solid blue state while campaigning Friday in Duluth, Minnesota. Biden met with...

After Embracing Past Shutdowns, House Dems Take More Defeated Stance on Stopgap

(Headline USA) House Democrats on Friday prepared a temporary spending bill that is needed to avert a government shutdown at the end of the...

Liz Cheney: Russia and China Using Leftist Environmental Groups to Influence US Policy

Rep. Liz Cheney, R-Wyo., asked the Justice Department this week to investigate some of the top leftist environmental groups, arguing that Russia and China...