Quantcast

Supreme Court Rejects Appeal for DC’s Representation in Congress

Both 'precedent' and 'the Constitution itself' explicitly reject the arguments for DC to be given statehood or equivalent representation....

The Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed an appeal that sought to give the District of Columbia representation in the House of Representatives, the Epoch Times reported.

Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch ruled in the case, Castañon v. United States, that the Supreme Court does not have jurisdiction over the matter.

Thomas and Gorsuch cited the court’s decision in Adams v. Clinton, a ruling from 2000 that said D.C. cannot have federal representation in the House because it is not a state and thus does not meet the US Constitution’s requirement for representation.

Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution authorizes Congress to create a “District (not exceeding ten Miles square)” that “may, by Cession of Particular States, and the Acceptance of Congress, become the Seat of the Government of the United States.”

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

The Founders envisioned this District as an administrative area for Congress, the president and his subordinate departments, and the Supreme Court to exercise their functions.

They feared that a federal district within a state’s jurisdiction would cause that state to capture the federal government and use it for its own purposes—to the detriment of the Union as a whole.

The Supreme Court’s ruling upheld a federal district court’s decision from March 2020.

Three judges on the lower court found that both “precedent” and “the Constitution itself” forced them to deny representation to the D.C., though they lamented that people found the decision “deeply unjust.”

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

The lawsuit does not appear to be connected to the Democratic Party’s bid to make Washington, D.C., the nation’s 51st state.

With D.C.’s statehood, the Democrats hope to gain two permanent Democratic senators and one permanent Democratic representative.

The District of Columbia would be the nation’s most solidly blue state—far more Democratic than Vermont or California.

The 23rd Amendment has already distorted the Founders’ initial design by giving three Electoral College votes to D.C. and thus empowering federal bureaucrats to vote for a president who will keep them in power.

- Advertisement -

TRENDING NOW

Trump Says He Wouldn’t Have Needed Vax Mandates: ‘I Would Convince People’

Former President Donald Trump said he would "convince people" to receive the COVID-19 shots by explaining their benefits, rather than politicizing them further through...

British Gov’t Prohibits Teaching Woke Racial Theories as Fact

The British government has put strict restraints on the teaching of "white privilege" as fact-based knowledge, the Epoch Times reported. Several months ago, the UK Parliament’s...

SHOCK VIDEO: Urgent-Care Doctor Appears to Refuse Child’s Treatment Due to Vax Status

A video posted to Twitter on Thursday appeared to show a doctor at an urgent-care facility in Fort Wayne, Indiana, refusing care to a...

REPORT: Schools That Hire ‘Diversity Officers’ Show Greater Achievement Gaps

It is becoming increasingly clear that the Left's "woke" stranglehold over public education is bad for students of all races, and that it is...

China’s New Claim: Maine Lobsters (Not Lab Leak) Spread COVID to Wuhan

Chinese diplomats and internet trolls have come up with a novel, if disingenuous, idea about the source of the COVID-19 pandemic, said NBC News...

Alec Baldwin Kills Cinematographer on Movie Set

(Headline USA) Actor and notorious left-wing rageaholic Alec Baldwin fired a prop gun on a movie set and killed the cinematographer, authorities said. The director...

In Va. Race, McAuliffe Faces ‘Nightmare’ Scenario: A Challenge from the Left

(Headline USA) The antithesis of everything black Virginians stand for---elite, white former Gov. Terry McAuliffe, a New York native, is at his element wooing...

Rand Paul Refers Lying Fauci to DOJ; Doubts Partisan AG ‘Will Have Time’ to Pursue

In an appearance Thursday on Fox News Primetime, Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., reprimanded COVID czar Anthony Fauci for lying to the Senate about whether...

Left’s Bid to Smear Jan. 6-Linked Lawmakers Winds Up Giving Them ‘Cred’ Instead

Attempts by Democrats to shame 21 conservative lawmakers by tying them to the Jan. 6 uprising at the US Capitol and rhetoric claiming vote...
- Advertisement -