Florida AG: ‘Bombshell New Evidence’ Discovered in Lawsuit over Biden Deportation Policies

() Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody said her office received “bombshell new evidence” that the Biden administration “wrongfully withheld” from her office until just days before they went to trial on Monday.

Her office filed a lawsuit last year against the Biden administration over altering federal immigration deportation policy, including expanding a parole program President Joe Biden announced last week that he planned to expand.

Moody is asking the court to halt the administration’s implementation of the policy, arguing it violates federal law and is unconstitutional.

Her team presented the new evidence on Monday as part of Florida’s case heard by the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Florida Pensacola Division that “the federal government wrongfully withheld until just before trial,” she said.

Her office received the information only through a Freedom of Information Act request, she said, when it should have received it during the discovery process.

Had her office not filed the FOIA request, she said, “the damning evidence would not come to light or be part of the State’s vital litigation to force the Biden administration to follow the law, secure the border and protect the American people.”

Moody is referring to copies of four pages of emails obtained by her office from the Department of Homeland Security in which officials include talking points for Border Patrol Chief Raul Ortiz to use when discussing releasing illegal foreign nationals into the U.S. en masse. The emails are dated Jan. 28, 2021, eight days after Biden took office.

The talking points are consistent with testimony given by Ortiz in a deposition last year in which he confirmed there was a border crisis and agents were required to release people en masse into the U.S.

One email explains the situation agents were faced with in response to the Biden administration terminating Trump-era policies designed to curtail illegal immigration.

It states, “The pause on processing pathways (MPP, ACA, PACR) and recent policy changes have also impacted USBP’s ability to expeditiously process and remove those encountered … The USBP will be required to promptly process and release family units and single adults due to lack of adjudication pathways.”

This refers to the administration no longer adhering to the Migrant Protection Protocols, otherwise known as the Remain in Mexico policy, which a federal court has required the administration continue. Texas sued over MPP, and the case is still in litigation.

ACA refers to the Trump-era Asylum Cooperation Agreement, which DHS entered into with the governments of Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras on Dec. 29, 2020.

The agreement enabled the federal government to more easily “remove certain eligible migrants seeking humanitarian protection to each of the ACA countries.”

PACR refers to a fast-track asylum review process (Prompt Asylum Claim Review), which helped expedite this process.

Biden’s reversal of these policies contributed to unprecedented numbers of people attempting to enter the U.S. from Northern Triangle countries. The majority aren’t believed to have valid asylum claims, Moody and others have argued.

After the federal government released and flew them nationwide in the middle of the night, including to Jacksonville, Florida sued.

Since Biden’s been in office, over 5 million foreign nationals have been apprehended or reported evading capture from law enforcement, including over 3.3 million in fiscal 2022 alone. Unless courts rule against the administration in multiple lawsuits brought against it, and their rulings are enforced, these numbers are expected to astronomically increase.

DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas last week, while claiming “the border is closed,” announced he planned to increase the processing and release of even more people into the U.S. once the public health authority Title 42 is lifted.

Notably, one of the talking points in an email thread states, “Mexico recently passed a law that precludes Mexican immigrants from detaining children, even if they are accompanied by adults/relatives/parents. This further impacts BP’s ability to expel family units under CDC T42 authority.”

The email implies that Mexican law has been dictating U.S. immigration detention and deportation policies, as critics have told the Center Square, also providing insight into Mayorkas altering Title 42 enforcement policies to rarely expel family units.

The email also states that in January 2021, BP agents were experiencing consecutive days of over 3,000 apprehensions a day and a continued surge of unaccompanied minors and family units would “immediately overwhelm USBP’s short term detention capacity … with an increased risk due to the COVID-19 pandemic.”

Instead of detaining or deporting family units who had the coronavirus, agents were instructed to release them, prompting Democratic run cities like Laredo to sue.

Texas counties filed disaster declarations in April 2021 over the policy and Texas Gov. Greg Abbott issued a disaster declaration May 31, 2021.

Moody says the records her office obtained “through our aggressive litigation efforts prove the Biden administration knew—as early as eight days after taking office—its destructive immigration policies were creating a colossal public safety crisis.

The evidence that we fought ferociously to obtain is damning for the Biden administration, and we will continue to use his administration’s own actions and words against them in an attempt to force the president to follow the law.”

Ex-NBA Star Exposes the Hypocrisy of NBA’s Woke Virtue Signaling

(Ezekiel Loseke, Headline USA) Enes Kanter Freedom, a former star center in the NBA, exposed the hypocrisy of the NBA’s woke virtue signaling in a long form interview with renowned libertarian journalist John Stossel.

Stossel opened the interview describing Freedom’s protest against communist China, which led to China banning his team’s games and the player himself reportedly being blackballed by the NBA.

“That’s strange,” Stossel noted. “The NBA encourages protests about injustice in America.”

Stossel pointed out that the NBA has funded several anti-police and anti-American commercials, painted “Black Lives Matter” on its courts, and even encouraged players to kneel during the national anthem.

Freedom—who had his last name legally changed to call attentioned to his activism— explained to Stossel that he’d been politically active since the second year of his NBA career.

Early on, NBA had always supported his political activism. But that, he noted, was when he was criticizing his home country of Turkey, not China.

“China, it turns out, must not be criticized by an NBA player,” Stossel clarified, adding that “Kanter [Freedom] lost his job.”

Freedom went on to say that his activism against China was initially motivated by his attempt to avoid hypocrisy after being confronted by a fan about the Uyghur populations in Western China that have been forced into labor camps—and worse.

The fan asked him, “How can you call yourself a human rights activist when your Muslim brothers and sisters are getting tortured and raped every day in concentration camps in China?” Freedom recalled.

He took the challenge seriously, researched the abuses, and spoke out against the tyranny of communist China.

“When it comes to problems [that] are happening in America[,] [t]hey’re the first organization [to speak out],” he said. “[The NBA says] this is wrong. This is what should happen, blah, blah, blah right?”

Freedom explained that the ratings of the NBA go a long way toward demonstrating that the league’s protection of China is all about money.

“More people watch[ed] NBA games in China last year than [the] American population,” he reported. “Over 450 million [Chinese] people watched NBA games.”

Freedom reported that during a conversation with league commissioner Adam Silver, Silver blatantly lied about China canceling Celtics games and was willing to distort the truth to prevent a threat to their Chinese market.

Likewise, he reported speaking to other players who would agree with him privately but would not risk their endorsements, shoe deals or NBA contracts to oppose the communist tyranny.

Freedom clarified that there is more money in China for NBA owners than TV revenue.

“Forty NBA owners got tied up $10 billion in China,” he said.

Freedom specifically called out Lakers star Lebron James, an outspoken left-wing activist with whom he has feuded in the past, for his decision to turn a blind eye to China.

“When the things that you talk about affects your money and business, you’re going to shut up about it,” he said.

Stossel pushed back on Freedom, saying that the NBA stands with BLM and no Asian hate.

Freedom further pointed out that the NBA also purports to stand with Latinos, “the LGBTQ community” and “so many things that are happening in America.”

However, he highlighted a critical difference.

The NBA’s activism, “is not going to cost any money,” he said. The NBA opposes activism “as soon as the things that they talk about … cost them money.”

Recent examples may be the NBA’s decisions to back off its endorsement of BLM just a year after it embraced the protests and to mandate the playing of the national anthem at its games.

Freedom reported that the obvious hypocrisy regarding China has led to the exposure of the NBA’s total moral corruption.

“When it comes to China, now the whole world knows that they are bowed down to money and business and they have no morals, no values or no prayer principles,” he said.

Aging Calif. Sen. Dianne Feinstein to Face 2024 Primary Challenge from Rep. Katie Porter

(Headline USA) Democratic Rep. Katie Porter of California said Tuesday she will seek the U.S. Senate seat currently held by Sen. Dianne Feinstein, a fellow Democrat and the oldest member of the chamber.

“Especially in times like these, California needs a warrior in Washington,” Porter said in a video posted on Twitter. “That’s exactly why I’m announcing my candidacy for the United States Senate in 2024.”

Porter was first elected to Congress in 2018 and won a tight race for reelection to her newly redrawn Southern California district in November. She said in the video that she has “challenged the status quo” in Washington, taking on “big banks,” Wall Street and the pharmaceutical industry. She wants to ban members of Congress from stock trading.

“To win these fights, it’s time for new leadership in the U.S. Senate,” she said.

Feinstein, 89, has faced questions about her age and memory and whether she will seek another term. She has not announced whether she will seek reelection in 2024, though she is widely expected to retire.

Feinstein won her sixth election in 2018 and has been a force for Democrats, serving for a time as chair of the intelligence and judiciary committees. But she also has seen pushback from Democrats who view her as too bipartisan at a time when politics is more polarized and her state is increasingly liberal.

In 2020, Feinstein announced she would step down as the top Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee. The move followed criticism that she was too friendly with Republicans during confirmation hearings for Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett. That included an embrace of the Republican Chairman, Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, at the conclusion of the hearings and kind words for what she called a job well done.

Feinstein has defended her performance and said in 2021 that she planned to serve her full term, even as there was open speculation and discussion about the future of the seat. Gov. Gavin Newson said in 2021 that he would appoint a black woman to replace Feinstein, who’s white, if she were to retire early.

Porter, 49, was a consumer protection attorney before her election to the House, and she has earned a reputation for her performative questioning of CEOs and other witnesses at congressional hearings—often using a whiteboard to break down information.

Porter’s showmanship was again on display during the recent GOP negotiations in the U.S. House over the election of a new speaker. As Republicans argued, Porter was seen sitting in the chamber, disinterestedly, reading a book on “the subtle art” of not caring about what’s happening.

Adapted from reporting by the Associated Press

Biden Admin’s Student-Loan Cash-Grab to Proceed, With or Without Amnesty

(Headline USA) Despite legal setbacks to its student-loan amnesty plan, the White House said it was moving forward with a proposal that it claimed would lower student debt payments for millions of Americans now and in the future, offering a new route to repay federal loans under far more generous terms.

That, in turn, would inevitably reduce the revenue that the government receives from the public lending program, while still failing to address the root cause of profligate spending and tuition hikes at universities that increasingly offer less value and return on the investment.

President Joe Biden announced the repayment plan in August, but it was overshadowed by his controversial plan to transfer student debt for 40 million Americans onto the backs of taxpayers at large.

Education Department officials on Tuesday called the new plan a “student loan safety net” that will prevent borrowers from getting overloaded with debt.

“Student debt has become a dream killer,” Education Secretary Miguel Cardona said. “This is a promise to the American people that, at long last, we will fix a broken system and make student loans affordable.”

Biden is moving forward with the repayment plan even as his one-time debt cancellation faces an uncertain fate before the Supreme Court.

The White House has asked the court to reject two legal challenges from conservative opponents who contend that he had no such authority under the U.S. Constitution to cancel public debt and that the program harms those who either paid their loans in good faith or never had them to begin with.

The Biden administration submitted its brief last week, with oral arguments slated for Feb. 28.

The Education Department formally proposed the new repayment plan on Tuesday by publishing it in the Federal Register, starting a public comment period that often takes months to navigate.

If it’s finalized, the proposal would give a major overhaul to income-driven repayment plans—one of several payment options offered by the federal government.

The resulting plan would have lower monthly payments, an easier path to forgiveness and a promise that unpaid interest will not be added to a borrower’s loan balance.

The federal government now offers four types of income-driven plans, but the proposal would mostly phase out three of them while focusing on one simplified option, scaling back the confusing array of options borrowers now face.

Under existing plans, monthly payments are capped at 10% of a borrower’s discretionary income, and those earning less than $20,400 a year aren’t required to make payments. The new proposal would cap payments for undergraduate loans at 5% of borrowers’ pay, cutting their bills in half, and require payments only for those who earn more than about $30,000 a year.

As long as borrowers make their monthly payments, any unpaid interest would not be charged. The change is meant to prevent borrowers from having unpaid interest added to their loan balance, a practice that can cause debt to snowball even as borrowers make payments.

Significantly, the proposal would also make it easier to get debt erased after making several years of payments.

Existing plans promise to cancel any remaining debt after 20 or 25 years of payments. The new plan would erase all remaining debt after 10 years for those who took out $12,000 or less in loans. For every $1,000 borrowed beyond that, a year would be added.

Typical graduates of a four-year university would save about $2,000 a year compared with today’s plans, the Biden administration says, while 85% of community college borrowers would be debt-free within 10 years.

Opponents on the right blast the revamped plan as an unfair handout with a steep price tag. The Biden administration estimates the repayment plan would cost nearly $138 billion over the decade, and some critics have put it closer to $200 billion.

Even some on the left have questioned the prudence of the idea, saying it’s so generous that it effectively turns student loans into grants that don’t need to be repaid. That could lead more students to borrow, they warn, and it could spur colleges to raise tuition prices if they know students won’t be on the hook.

Still others have urged the administration to abandon income-driven payment plans entirely, calling them a failed policy. Critics cite a federal report from last year finding that sloppy oversight of the program left thousands of borrowers stuck with debt that should have been forgiven.

Cardona said his agency is working on other proposals that would hold colleges accountable if their students get overburdened with debt. One idea promoted by Biden is to warn the public about programs that leave graduates saddled with debt.

The Education Department on Tuesday began the process to deliver that goal, asking the public about the best way to identify “low-value” programs.

Adapted from reporting by the Associated Press

As Populist Uprising Rattles Brazil, Bolsonaro Finds Home in Fla.

(Headline USA) As Brazil’s new leftist government reels from mobs of outraged voters protesting the suspicious circumstances surrounding its recent election, former conservative leader Jair Bolsonaro has decamped to a Florida resort, where droves of supporters flock to cheer on their exiled president.

Devotees have traveled in recent days to Bolsonaro’s temporary home, a gated community with towering waterslides, for a chance to see him. He signed autographs, hugged children and took selfies with adoring masses, some sporting “Make Brazil Great Again” shirts.

“I will always support him,” said 31-year-old Rafael Silva, who left Brazil eight years ago and now installs flooring in central Florida, where he stood outside Bolsonaro’s rental home Monday. “He was the best for the country.”

By early afternoon, the handful of supporters in yellow jerseys dissipated as word spread that Bolsonaro was hospitalized with abdominal pain.

His wife, Michelle, said on social media that he had been hospitalized for observation due to abdominal discomfort related to a 2018 stabbing that has led to multiple hospitalizations in the past.

A photo published by Brazilian newspaper O Globo showed him smiling from his hospital bed. A hospital spokesperson didn’t immediately respond to a phone call and text message.

Prior to Sunday’s populist uprising at  Brazil’s Congress, Supreme Court and presidential palace, Bolsonaro had been seen repeatedly in this central Florida community, wandering a Publix supermarket’s aisles, dining alone at a local KFC and, most of all, surrounded by clusters of adoring fans.

Though the Osceola County Sheriff’s Office said it received a request from the Secret Service to provide a police escort for Bolsonaro when he arrived and he was still a sitting president, he has not been surrounded by a noticeable phalanx of security.

Bolsonaro has long been called the “Trump of the Tropics,” so it may come as no surprise that he wound up just a few hours’ drive away from the former American president’s Palm Beach compound.

Rodrigo Constantino, a right-wing Brazilian commentator who lives in Florida, says he sees parallels between Bolsonaro’s support in the state and the re-election triumph of Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis. Both, he said, amounted to rejections of “the totalitarian, woke, economic egalitarianism and sensational demagogy of the radical left.”

Meanwhile, Trump-Deranged leftists seethed at the notion that Bolsonaro planned to seek safe harbor in the free state of Florida.

“He will make himself right at home in Florida’s right-wing ecosystem of grifting and podcasting, finding allies with whomever thinks they can use him to advance their far-right agenda,” bemoaned Andy Reiter, an associate professor of politics and international relations at Mount Holyoke College in Massachusetts.

Bolsonaro’s new abode, Encore Resort at Reunion in the suburbs of Orlando, is made up of furnished rental homes with foosball tables, screening rooms, Disney decor on the walls and Mickey Mouse stuffed animals on beds.

If it all seems too odd, the sight of the former leader of one of the world’s biggest countries wandering a gated community a stone’s throw from Walt Disney World in shorts, consider the history.

A stream of regional leaders have called the state home, at least for a time, over the past half century, from Haiti’s Prosper Avril to Nicaragua’s Anastasio Somoza to Panama’s Manuel Noriega.

Alongside a list of other Latin American notables, they’ve camped out in both modest homes and elaborate mansions and, in the case of Noriega, a Miami prison cell, where he served 17 years on drug charges.

When asked by reporters Monday if the U.S. would send Bolsonaro back to Brazil, national security adviser Jake Sullivan said the Biden administration hadn’t received any requests from Brazil related to the former president.

Brazilian Justice Minister Flavio Dino told reporters that, as of now, Brazil had no plans to ask the U.S. for Bolsonaro to be extradited.

A bevy of Brazilians have been lured to central Florida in the past two decades and have in turn transformed the region with scores of Brazilian shops and restaurants.

Florida has the largest population of residents who were born in Brazil—nearly 130,000 people—of any U.S. state, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey. Many more come as visitors, with 830,000 Brazilians traveling to central Florida in 2019, the third largest international market for the area.

Though Lula da Silva declared a victory in last year’s election by more than 2 million votes, Brazilian voters living in Florida appear to have heavily favored Bolsonaro. Election data for Brazilians living abroad showed 56 polling locations listed under Miami, the only Florida city under which data is compiled.

In each of the 56 areas, Bolsonaro prevailed, some by margins of 6-to-1. All told, more than 16,000 votes were counted among Brazilians under the Miami umbrella, with 81% favoring Bolsonaro.

“He is very popular with the Brazilian emigres in central Florida,” said Joel Stewart, former honorary consul for Brazil in Orlando. Brazil opened a consular office in Orlando last year.

Whatever anger might exist against Bolsonaro in Brazil, Constantino says Brazilians living in Florida will understand and accept him.

“If he wants to come to my house and eat barbecue and chat about soccer or talk bad about communism, he will be very well received,” Constantino said.

Adapted from reporting by the Associated Press

Number of ‘Female’ Pedophiles Rises as British Cops Start Recording Gender Identity

(Molly Bruns, Headline USA) The number of female pedophiles in the United Kingdom has increased by an astounding 84% since many police forces are now recording crimes based on gender identity as opposed to biological sex.

According to the Post Millennial, the BBC addressed this phenomenon in a 35-minute radio segment but at no point mentioned that many of the females sexually abusing children in the U.K. might actually be males.

The shift in crime records left many wanting for facts, including Labour MP Tonia Antoniazzi, who called for “accurate records of the biological sex of the victims and perpetrators of the crime, in addition to data on gender identity of victims and perpetrators.”

Antoniazzi argued that by recording suspects’ gender identity instead of their biological sex, there is no way of confirming if the “large increase is due to an increase in female offenders of those identifying as woman.”

“That detail matters,” she added.

Recording these crimes based on fantasies of perverted men instead of biological facts will cause the data to skew, as women generally make up a minuscule percentage of sex offense convictions.

“Where offense categories are very rarely committed by women, the addition of just one or two people can have a significant impact on data,” Antoniazzi argued.

The number of trans-identified male inmates convicted of sex offenses is much higher than non-trans-identified inmates—also known as women.

This indicates that either men who believe they are women are more likely to be sex offenders, or men who are sex offenders are attempting to soften the blow of the legal system by identifying as women. Male sex offenders may also be attempting to gain access to women’s prisons.

The U.K.—and some American states—imprison inmates according to their gender identity, allowing male sexual predators into spaces with many vulnerable women.

Brandy Wood, a serial sex offender and pedophile, requested a transfer to a women’s prison in Connecticut after identifying as intersex. According to the state’s sex offender registry, Wood is a “female.”

Failed Candidate Stacey Abrams Tells Ex-Junkie Actress She Plans to Run Again

(Jacob Bruns, Headline USA) Twice-failed radical leftist candidate Stacey Abrams recently committed to running for political office once again, Breitbart reported.

Abrams, who has lost twice to Georgia Republican Gov. Brian Kemp, told actress Drew Barrymore on her daytime talk show that she would be back again.

Barrymore—the former child actor turned Hollywood infant terrible—has sought yet another career reboot on her CBS-produced daytime show, which first aired last September.

Her disconcerting facial tics and shallow observations on lofty subjects like politics were balanced out by a remarkable buoyancy that lent the ex-drug addict an air of genuine empathy as an interviewer.

She opened the segment by flattering Abrams for her organizing prowess.

“You need to stay around,” Barrymore gushed. “You’ve been such a galvanizer.”

“I will likely run again,” Abrams said.

“If at first you don’t succeed, try try again,” Abrams continued, alluding to her dismal election track record. “If it doesn’t work, you try again.”

Abrams then descended into nonsensical jargon about the nature of democracy, noting that she would like the system to be arranged so as to increase her chance of winning.

“My first responsibility is to make sure anyone who wants to vote can,” she said. “Protecting democracy is not about a person. It’s about the ideals.”

Abrams refused to concede her 2018 loss, claiming that the election had been rigged in Kemp’s favor, and she fought against GOP led reforms to improve election integrity following a 2020 race that saw widespread allegations of ballot harvesting and fraud in Fulton County and elsewhere in the state.

Despite her claims that voter laws had disenfranchised black and minority voters, the 2020 and 2022 elections saw record turnouts.

Abrams told Barrymore that the American ideal of democracy was fundamentally an illusion that required all citizens to play along in order to function correctly.

“Our democracy is this collective hallucination we have where we we say we’re going to work together to help each other, and if anyone sort of blinks and comes out of it, like the Matrix, it starts to fall apart,” she said.

The 5-minute interview contained several other cringeworthy moments, such as Abrams admitting that her entire political project is a revenge plot against an ex-boyfriend who dumped her because she was too ambitious.

“He broke up with me and he said that I was too ambitious and wanted too many things and that I would end up alone and lonely,” said Abrams, who has penned at least eight erotic novels under the pseudonym Selena Montgomery.

“And so I got really mad, and then I was like, fine, I’m going to think of all the things I’m going to do to make him rue the day he was mean to me.”

The confession drew criticism from her former Georgia statehouse colleague Vernon Jones, a red-pilled ex-Democrat lawmaker who threw support to then-President Donald Trump in the 2020 election and ran unsuccessfully for Congress in the recent midterm election.

He said Abrams was a “sad and lonely woman.”

Dem. Mayors Write Letter to Colorado Concerning Busing of Illegals

(Molly Bruns, Headline USA) Democrat mayors sent a “cease and desist” letter to Democrat Colorado Gov. Jared Polis, entreating him to stop sending illegal immigrants to their cities.

According to the Post Millennial, mayors Eric Adams of New York City and Lori Lightfoot of Chicago levied the complaint against Polis on the grounds that “neither city had any additional room to accommodate any more migrants.”

They also called the practice “inhumane,” and claimed that “overburdening other cities is not the solution,” despite both of the city’s status as sanctuaries for illegals.

“Before the first bus arrived in either of our cities, we informed a Colorado official directly that neither city had any additional room to accommodate any more migrants because of the thousands of migrants that had already been inhumanely bused to our respective cities from Texas since spring of 2022,” the letter reads.

Adams took to the radio to complain about Polis’s move.

“This is just unfair for local governments to have to take on this national obligation,” he added. Adams did not express any concern for cities along the border that have been overrun by illegal aliens.

Denver Mayor Michael Hancock declared a state of emergency in December due to the influx of immigrant aliens from the US-Mexico border, prompting action from Polis.

“States and cities not on the border are ill-equipped to address these challenges, and absent federal support and leadership, we’re left to strategize and take actions to ensure this vulnerable population – people who’ve come here with no resources or means – are safe and treated humanely,” Hancock said in a statement.

Polis’s administration argued that they are assisting migrants in reaching their intended destinations, as 70% of them want to move farther north and east.

In response to the letter, Polis met with Adams and Lightfoot. After the meeting, he announced that there are “no more buses scheduled for migrants from Denver to Chicago at this time.”

The final bus will arrive in New York on Sunday.

Neither Adams nor Lightfoot rescinded their city’s status as a sanctuary city—where migrants can live without fear of deportation—despite their complaints about the increased migrant population.

NSA Urges SCOTUS to Reject Challenge to its Spying Powers

(Ken Silva, Headline USA) The U.S. National Security Agency is urging the Supreme Court to uphold a ruling that would essentially make its mass surveillance activities legally unchallengeable.

The ruling the NSA seeks to keep intact was made by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals in September 2021, when justices allowed the spy agency to exercise its “state secrets” privilege to quash a lawsuit from the Wikimedia Foundation.

Wikimedia had sued the NSA in 2015 over its “upstream” surveillance, which entails the agency monitoring all private emails, messages and other data flowing into and out of the country on the internet’s central arteries.

In response to the lawsuit, the NSA claimed it couldn’t defend itself in court without divulging sensitive state secrets that would jeopardize national security.

In a decision that critics said defied precedent, a lower court agreed with the NSA and tossed the lawsuit — without reviewing the evidence that the government sought to keep secret. The Fourth Circuit upheld the decision in September 2021, ruling that the lawsuit “cannot be fairly litigated any further without disclosure of state secrets.”

In August, Wikimedia filed a writ of certiorari with the Supreme Court, calling for the Fourth Circuit ruling to be reviewed.

Wikimedia argued that the Fourth Circuit was wrong to dismiss its lawsuit without reviewing the NSA’s claim that litigation would reveal state secrets. The organization explained that judges can review evidence in private to determine whether it should be excluded from open court, but that judges should not dismiss an entire case based on the state-secrets doctrine.

In its response filed Friday, the NSA disagreed. According to the spy agency, even if a judge reviewed sensitive evidence in private, the agency’s secrets would still be jeopardized.

“If a court were either to dismiss or decline to dismiss … after reviewing the government’s privileged (and highly classified) evidence on the matter, the dismissal would effectively reveal sensitive intelligence matters— state secrets—that cannot be publicly confirmed or denied without significant harm to the national security,” the NSA said in its brief.

Numerous civil liberties groups have criticized the NSA’s position on the matter, warning that it would allow government agencies to operate in secret without any judicial review.

A group of former federal judges also filed an amicus brief in the case last September, agreeing with the civil liberties organizations.

“A rule that allows the government to quash litigation merely by asserting it may have defenses involving sensitive information invites Executive overreach and error,” the former judges said in their brief. “The court should grant review to clarify that judges retain a meaningful role in evaluating claims of privilege, and that they should not, as a rule, blindly defer to the government’s assertion that litigating a case would disclose state secrets.”

SCOTUS has not indicated when it will decide whether the hear Wikimedia’s petition. Headline USA will continue to follow the case as it develops.

Ken Silva is a staff writer at Headline USA. Follow him at twitter.com/jd_cashless.

Joy Reid Says it’s ‘Disturbing’ that Republicans Want to Investigate Hunter Biden, Others

(Molly Bruns, Headline USA) During her Monday monologue, Joy Reid of MSNBC claimed that it is “disturbing” that Republicans are so interested in investigating the shady activities of first son Hunter Biden.

According to the Daily Caller, Reid was discussing Rep. Kevin McCarthy’s hard-won gain of the House Speaker’s seat and claimed that he made concessions to far-Right extremists in order to obtain the power.

“After a week of Republicans proving they are not fit to govern, as we speak they’re dealing with the basics of organizing Congress,” Reid said.

“Just moments ago, passing a new house rules package for MAGA extremists,” she added. “It includes a new rule allowing one member to force a vote of no confidence in the speaker, along with steep spending cuts and changes to rules on raising the debt limit.”

Reid insisted that looking into these things is “disturbing,” and called the House GOP a “kangaroo court.”

“Meanwhile, the investigations that Republicans are preparing to launch are equally disturbing,” she added. “Among them, what could only be called a Kangaroo court that will soon target the Department of Justice and the FBI, the president’s son, Hunter Biden, and judiciary subcommittee on quote ‘weaponization of the federal government.’”

Other investigations that Republicans want to initiate include looking into America’s withdrawal from Afghanistan, the origins of the COVID virus and the actions of Dr. Anthony Fauci throughout the pandemic.

Many Twitter users were disturbed by Reid’s take, and called her out on it.

The House also passed a rules package that would allow a single member to vacate the chair, a requirement that tax increases must receive 60% of the House’s support before becoming law and allows Representatives to have 72 hours to read bills.

Republicans are also creating a subcommittee under the House Judiciary Committee which will investigate politicians weaponization of the federal government.