Cities Likely to Use COVID Crisis to Ramp Up Abusive Fines and Fees

‘Whether municipalities engage in taxation by citation is ultimately a matter of local policy, but state policymakers should take a hard look…’

Cities Likely to Use COVID-19 Crisis to Ramp Up Abusive Fines and Fees
Police trail a group of social-distancing scofflaws in New York, where Gov. Andrew Cuomo has ordered fines up to $1,000 for noncompliance. / IMAGE: Eyewitness News ABC7NY via YouTube

(Michael Barnes, Liberty Headlines) As cities and towns face mounting financial woes due to the Wuhan coronavirus economic shutdown, they’re likely to ramp up predatory revenue streams without risking political blow-back from new tax proposals.

But according to the Institute for Justice, a public interest law firm, ordinary Americans—many of whom are already struggling with illness or unemployment—are going to pay the price of these “taxation by citation” schemes.

“Regardless of what municipalities need or what state laws allow, cities should use code enforcement only to protect the public, not to shore up their finances,” said Bill Maurer, a senior IJ lawyer.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

Maurer is the lead attorney on several lawsuits pushing back on citation schemes. He says state lawmakers have a crucial role to play in shutting down “municipal fines and fees abuse” because state legislatures can preempt local ordinances.

Cities and towns across the country habitually use traffic tickets, property code fines and other self-serving ordinances to raise revenue under the guise of public safety. But the Wuhan virus offers an unprecedented opportunity to scale-up.

Such schemes exploded in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis. Now, the Wuhan pandemic has created an economic downturn coupled with a once-in-a-lifetime public-health crisis where all levels of government have assumed previously unthinkable expansions of power.

Accordingly, cash-hungry local politicians are poised to push citation abuse to new levels.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

It’s already happening in some places. Earlier this month, the Marshall Project reported jurisdictions nationwide are aggressively pursuing court debts and even issuing new fines while courts and other public offices are closed.

In response, the Institute for Justice has released a report, “Municipal Fines and Fees: A 50-State Survey of State Laws,” that identifies a wide range of laws enabling citation abuses. The report is a comprehensive accounting that uses 52 legal factors to rank all 50 states.

Georgia is the worst-ranking state in the country. Georgia’s state legal framework gives broad authority for cities to enact codes and enforce them in their own courts while denying common-sense protections against unjust convictions.

North Carolina, on the other hand, ranks highest. North Carolina’s legal environment is the least conducive to municipal fines and fees abuse because it does not allow cities and towns to operate their own courts. It also prohibits jailing people or suspending their driver’s licenses when they cannot pay fines and fees—unless they’re willfully noncompliant.

The ACLU disagrees, however. The progressive legal organization asserts that North Carolina engages in debtors’ prisons, where “thousands of low-income people are in jail, trapped in a cycle of debt, or both, because they cannot afford the unconstitutional fines and fees that courts order them to pay when convicted of any crime, even as minor as a speeding ticket.”

Whatever the case, more than 840 cities and towns across the country generate more than 10 percent of their annual revenues from tickets, fines and fees, according to the nonpartisan Governing magazine.

“Whether municipalities engage in taxation by citation is ultimately a matter of local policy, but state policymakers should take a hard look at how state laws may be contributing to the problem,” said Dick Carpenter, director of strategic research at IJ and co-author of the report.

- Advertisement -


Biden Admin Admits to Secretly Smuggling Immigrant Kids into NY, Other States

President Joe Biden's administration was forced to admit it has been smuggling illegal immigrant minors into New York by plane at night, following a...

Sheriffs Reject Lightfoot’s Call for Backup as Chicago Police Quit over Vax Mandate

Two Illinois sheriffs said they would not send their deputies to fill in Chicago’s staffing shortages as Democrat Mayor Lori Lightfoot tries to force...

Illegal Immigration Arrests Highest They’ve Been Since 1986

Under the Biden administration, US Border Patrol arrests reached the highest levels this past year since 1986, according to recently released data from US...

McAuliffe Has Mid-Interview Meltdown, Tells Reporter to Ask ‘Better Questions’

With his once dominant lead in rapid decline against a political newcomer, former Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe---also the state's current Democratic gubernatorial candidate---stormed out...

CRAPO: Dems Attempting Bait-and-Switch w/ ‘Revised’ IRS Spying Scheme

Sen. Mike Crapo, R-Idaho blasted a revised Democrat proposal that would allow the IRS to track bank accounts of virtually every American by establishing...

Dems Block Bill to Protect Vax Holdouts from Losing Social Security, Gov’t Benefits

Democrats in the Senate this week blocked a bill by Sen. Rick Scott, R-Fla., that would have prevented the government from mandating vaccines for...

Texas Gov. Abbott Splits w/ Conservatives over Property Tax Reform

(Bethany Blankley, The Center Square) After the third special legislative session ended, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott issued a statement praising the accomplishments of the...

Poll Gives Mixed Report on NY Gov. Hochul’s Early Favorability, Re-Election Prospects

(Steve Bittenbender, The Center Square) A new Siena College poll that came out Tuesday shows mostly good news for New York Gov. Kathy Hochul. However,...

NJ Launches Program to Give Tax Dollars to Illegals

(T.A. DeFeo, The Center Square) New Jersey taxpayers are on the hook for $40 million in one-time payments for undocumented people living in the...
- Advertisement -