Quantcast

POLL: 1.8M People Didn’t Return to Work Because of Generous Welfare Benefits

System offered many unemployed households the equivalent of $25/hour in benefits for staying home...

(Brad Polumbo, Foundation for Economic Education) Here are FEE, we predicted from the beginning of the pandemic that Congress’s decision to create an unemployment benefits system paying most individuals more on welfare than they earned by working would backfire.

We weren’t the only ones.

The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office similarly cautioned that this move would cause unemployment and hurt the economy.

The system has offered many unemployed households the equivalent of $25/hour in benefits for staying home. It was always obviously illogical, based on the work disincentive it creates. However, in the year and a half since, there has been an enormous, concentrated, politically motivated effort to deny that the excessively generous welfare benefits are playing any role at all in joblessness.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

A new poll makes this continued denial impossible.

For context, we currently have 1.2 unemployed people for every unfilled job opening. Small businesses are also reporting massive shortages of willing workers, even as they raise wages.

So, Morning Consult surveyed unemployed Americans and asked them why they turned down job offers. About 13 percent openly admitted their reason for not returning to work was “I receive enough money from unemployment insurance without having to work.”

If this representative sample is extrapolated across the entire unemployed population, that equates to 1.8 million Americans who admitted to declining to go back to work because they could earn more on welfare.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

Meanwhile, another 12.1 percent said that they were not offered enough money to return to work. This subjective determination is likely also influenced by the generous benefits as a fall-back option.

Here is a graph from Axios showing the full results:

Image Credit: Axios

Here we have solid confirmation that millions of people have remained unemployed because of the federal government’s reckless expansion of the welfare state.

This is, on its face, even more vindication for the many conservative-leaning states that canceled the benefits early. And it offers even more compelling weight to the argument that the federal welfare expansion ought to be allowed to lapse in September as scheduled. (There will undoubtedly be a push to extend it; the “temporary” program has already been extended several times.)

But the Morning Consult poll results are also, most likely, a wild underestimate.

Just think about it: Would you admit, if a pollster called you up, that you’re lazily staying on benefits because it pays more than working? Probably not. There’s a very real phenomenon in polling results where people, quite naturally, skew toward offering answers that are more flattering to them than the unadulterated truth. We can’t know the full extent, but I think it’s safe to assume that the real figure is much higher than 1.8 million.

Of course, we never should have needed poll results to tell us that disincentivizing work would lead to fewer people working. That’s what basic economics taught us all along…Original Source

- Advertisement -

TRENDING NOW

WHERE’S HIPPA? State to Text Pennsylvanians Who Missed 2nd COVID-19 Shot

(Christen Smith, The Center Square) In an effort to boost the statewide COVID-19 vaccination rate, the Pennsylvania Department of Health said residents who missed their...

‘1619 Project’, Touted as ‘Racial Reckoning’, Ignores Democrat Party Racism

(Mark Hemingway, RealClearInvestigations) Democrats who advanced a bill in June to remove statues of white supremacists from the U.S. Capitol ignored a central fact...

Biden Plans Vax Mandate for Foreign Visitors… Except Those at Border?

(Headline USA) As illegal immigration helps drive the second major wave of the coronavirus pandemic in pro-freedom states where many remain unvaccinated, foreigners who...

Dems Concerned After Facebook Censors NYU Researchers over Ads Project

(Headline USA) Two Democrats who have been supportive of Facebook's censorship of conservative dissenters expressed their 'concern' about the company's suppression of left-wing research...

Pennsylvania Dems Demand Photo ID to Buy Ammo… But Not to Vote

Democratic lawmakers in Pennsylvania have introduced two bills to restrict and tax ammunition purchases, as well as to number and monitor each round sold,...

Whole Foods CEO: Businesses ‘Taking Political Positions’ Is a ‘Mistake’

Whole Foods CEO John Mackey on Tuesday said it is a "mistake" for businesses to express political opinions, the Epoch Times reported. "They should be...

Left Mystified as McConnell Signals Support for $1T Infrastructure Package

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., had vowed to be “100% focused” on stopping President Joe Biden’s agenda. But when it comes to the pending...

JUSTICE DEPT.: Many Reentering Arizona Illegally are Repeat Violent Criminals

(Bethany Blankley, The Center Square) Many who have entered the U.S. illegally have already been convicted of killing Americans, says a report by the U.S...

Texas Congressman Says State Should Shut Down ALL Roads from Mexico Border

Rep. Chip Roy, R-Texas, argued his home state should consider shutting down all roads that connect to Mexico, to force the Biden administration to...
- Advertisement -