Facebook Oversight Board Members Blast ‘Inconsistent’ Rules after Trump Ban

Content moderation rules are 'not transparent, they are unclear, they are internally inconsistent...'

At least two members of Facebook’s Oversight Board, which upheld the social media company’s ban on former president Donald Trump’s account last week, have come out against the decision, warning that Facebook has too much power.

Former Danish Prime Minister Helle Thorning–Schmidt, a board member, said last week that Facebook’s indefinite ban of Trump is an unprecedented punishment.

“Facebook invented their own sanctions as they looked into this particular user, Trump,” she told Axios. “Why is this user, Trump, any more special than anyone else? To be punished differently, in ways Facebook chooses to.”

Thorning–Schmidt explained Facebook’s permanent ban was not even an option in the platform’s community guidelines until the company invented a new rule to issue the ban.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

This is why the board ruled that Facebook needs to reevaluate its decision to come up with a “proportionate response that is consistent with the rules that are applied to other users of its platforms,” she added.

Facebook’s decision to hand off this debate to the Oversight Board was “lazy,” Thorning–Schmidt said, noting the board was not created to lift responsibility off Facebook or help them justify new rules it creates along the way.

Another Board member, Michael McConnell, agreed and warned that Facebook “exercises too much power.” 

“They did not provide any reasons for that,” McConnell said of Facebook’s decision to ban Trump’s account. “That is not a provision in their rules. That was wrong.”

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

He went on to say that Facebook’s content-moderation rules were “not transparent, they are unclear, they are internally inconsistent.”

What Facebook should have done is remove Trump’s posts on the day of the Jan. 6 Capitol uprising, which violated Facebook’s rules, said McConnell. But that is where the company should have stopped, he argued.

“They are arbitrary. They are inconsistent. And it is the job of the Oversight Board to try to bring some discipline to that process,” he said.

- Advertisement -


CDC: Afghanis Potentially Spreading Infectious Diseases

(Bethany Blankley, The Center Square) The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) is recommending that medical professionals and clinicians be on alert for...

New Non-Laptop Emails Show More Hunter Biden Ties to China

President Joe Biden's son, Hunter Biden, attempted to acquire an annual $2-million retainer to aid in the recovery of Libyan assets frozen by President...

88-Year-Old Chuck Grassley Will Seek Re-Election to Senate Seat

(Associated Press) Iowa Sen. Chuck Grassley, the longest-serving Republican senator, said Friday that he will seek an eighth term in 2022, giving the party more...

Former Colleague Accuses CNN’s Chris Cuomo of Sex Harassment

CNN’s Chris Cuomo has been accused of sexual harassment by a former female manager at ABC News. In an op-ed for the New York Times,...

Pa. AG Sues State Republicans to Stop Election Audit Subpoenas

Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro filed a lawsuit against the state GOP this week to block Republican legislators from subpoenaing election officials for its...

Banks Band Together to Oppose Biden’s IRS Plan to Snoop on Private Accounts

President Joe Biden and his administration face heavy criticism as they push a plan to give the Internal Revenue Service permission to delve into...

Biden Admin Disobeys Judge’s Order; Drags Feet on Oil, Gas Leases

(Bob Pepalis, The Center Square) The Biden administration is delaying lease sales of federal lands for oil and gas exploration even after a court order,...

U.S. Government Plans to Default on Debt the Dishonest Way

(Mike Gleason, Money Metals News Service) Debt troubles in China and Washington, D.C. helped boost safe-haven demand for precious metals early this week. By Thursday, however,...

Walensky Overrides CDC Advisory Panel; Widens Access to COVID Vax Booster

(Associated Press) The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on Thursday endorsed booster shots for millions of older or otherwise vulnerable Americans, opening a major...
- Advertisement -