Quantcast

Elon Musk to Testify Before Court About Tesla’s Acquisition of Solar Company

'I think Elon believes this was the right deal and still does...'

(Headline USA) In the runup to Tesla Inc.’s 2016 acquisition of a company called SolarCity, Elon Musk hailed the deal as a “no brainer” — a purchase that would combine the leading maker of electric vehicles with a manufacturer of solar panels that can recharge EVs.

It didn’t exactly work out that way.

On Monday in the Delaware Court of Chancery, the Tesla CEO will testify about the $2.5 billion deal in a shareholder lawsuit that alleges that Tesla’s acquisition was rife with conflicts of interest, overlooked SolarCity’s fundamental weaknesses and unsurprisingly failed to produce the profits Musk had promised.

Questioned under oath, Musk plans to defend the purchase as a justifiable acquisition.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

At the time of the all-stock purchase, Musk was SolarCity’s largest stakeholder and its chairman.

Seven shareholder lawsuits, consolidated into one, alleged that Tesla directors breached their fiduciary duties in bowing to Musk’s wishes and agreeing to buy the struggling company.

In what the plaintiffs call a clear conflict of interest, SolarCity had been founded by Musk and two of his cousins, Lyndon and Peter Rive.

Last August, a judge approved a $60 million settlement that resolved claims made against all the directors on Tesla’s board except Musk without any admission of fault.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

That left Musk, who refused to settle, as the sole remaining defendant. The trial that begins Monday had been scheduled for March of last year but was postponed because of widespread hysteria about a flu-like illness, COVID-19.

Daniel Ives, an analyst at Wedbush Securities, called the acquisition a “clear black eye” for Musk and Tesla, in large part because SolarCity has failed to turn a profit.

“It basically was putting good money after bad,” Ives said. “For all the successes and all of the unimaginable heights Musk has achieved, this is one of the lowlights.”

Most investors, Ives said, place no value on the company’s solar business.

“I just think Musk and Tesla underestimated the challenges and the hurdles that the business brings,” he said.

That said, Ives said he thought Tesla’s energy business could still become “modestly successful.”

Tesla, which has disbanded its media relations department, did not answer a message Friday seeking comment about the lawsuit.

In its 2020 annual report, the company argued that the lawsuit was without merit and that Tesla would vigorously defend itself.

“We are unable to estimate the possible loss or range of loss, if any, associated with these claims,” the company report said.

Tesla’s energy generation and storage business generated $1.9 billion in revenue last year — 24% more than it did the previous year.

Much of that revenue came from selling battery storage units. Tesla doesn’t specify whether the business made a profit, and it also has debt and expenses.

The lawsuit filed by the plaintiffs contends that Musk drove the decision to acquire SolarCity despite his clear-cut conflict of interest.

Musk has a history of fighting government agencies and lawsuits.

He was forced to pay a $20 million fine to the Securities and Exchange Commission for making statements on Twitter about having the money to take the company private when he didn’t.

Even if the trial ends with Musk having to pay personally for the whole SolarCity deal, $2.5 billion won’t much hurt the world’s third-wealthiest person. Forbes magazine has estimated that Musk is worth roughly $163 billion.

Ives suggested that while any such payment wouldn’t seriously affect Musk’s wealth, it would damage his reputation for choosing acquisitions.

Musk is fighting the lawsuit after others have settled “because that’s what Musk does,” Ives said. “I think Elon believes this was the right deal and still does.”

Adapted from reporting by the Associated Press.

- Advertisement -

TRENDING NOW

Biden Admin Looks to Send Haitian Migrants to Gitmo

The Biden administration was reportedly looking to set up a migrant detention facility at Guantanamo Bay as it struggles to get control of the...

Rubio Legislation Would Let Shareholders Sue Woke Corporations

Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., on Thursday introduced legislation that would force corporate boards and managers to prove that their far-left social ideologies benefit shareholders,...

$1 Trillion Coins Instead of More Federal Debt?!

Credit risk out of China and debt ceiling drama in Washington are driving precious metals markets this week. Gold and silver attracted some significant safe-haven...

Biden Adviser Jake Sullivan Tied to 2016 Clinton Scheme to Tar Trump

(Paul Sperry, RealClearInvestigations) White House National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan figures prominently in a grand jury investigation run by Special Counsel John Durham into...

Cuomo Official Behind Disastrous COVID-Nursing Home Policy RESIGNS

(Headline USA) New York Health Commissioner Howard Zucker, who was a leading defender of former Gov. Andrew Cuomo's response to the COVID-19 pandemic, has submitted...

Mexico Doesn’t Want Haitians Amassing on Their Side of the Border EITHER

(Associated Press) A camp where more than 14,000 migrants had waited along the Texas border just days ago was dramatically smaller at dawn Thursday, while...

Federal Judge Rules Fla.’s Sanctuary City Ban Unconstitutional

(John Haughey, The Center Square) Florida will appeal a federal judge’s injunction prohibiting the state from enforcing its two-year-old sanctuary cities ban. U.S. Southern District of...

FDA Official: ‘Blow Dart’ African Americans with COVID Vaccine

(Project Veritas) Project Veritas released the second video of its COVID vaccine investigative series today exposing U.S. Food and Drug Administration economist, Taylor...

Jobless Claims Rise 351,000 in Surprise Jump

(Headline USA) The number of Americans applying for unemployment aid rose last week for a second straight week to 351,000, a sign that the Biden...
- Advertisement -