(Ken Silva, Headline USA) A federal judge has denied YouTuber Candace Owens’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit filed against her by conservative activist Charlie Kirk’s former bodyguard, Brian Harpole.
Harpole sued Owens in April after she aired allegations from a man named Mitch Snow that he saw Harpole, Kirk’s widow Erika Kirk, and Army intelligence officers at Fort Huachuca in Arizona before Charlie’s assassination. Snow’s supposed sighting has fueled conspiracy theories that the group was plotting Charlie’s death. Snow is also a party to the lawsuit.
In her August motion to dismiss, Owens argued that Harpole’s lawsuit should be tossed because her statements about him were “inactionable opinions, rhetorical hyperbole, and questions incapable of a defamatory meaning.” She also argued that Harpole hasn’t proven “actual malice,” nor has he plausibly alleged that he was damaged by her.
“The most obvious explanation for Plaintiff’s reputational harm is that the person Plaintiff was hired to protect was assassinated on his watch,” her motion added.
However, a judge disagreed on Friday, ruling that Harpole’s lawsuit “includes enough facts to clear the low bar of plausibility.”
The case will now proceed to discovery.
Kirk was shot while addressing a crowd at the University of Utah on Sept. 10, 2025. The suspect, Tyler Robinson, has been charged in connection with the killing.
Harpole, for his part, has previously blamed local police for failing to protect campus rooftops, allowing a gunman to fatally shoot his client.
Ken Silva is the editor of Headline USA. Follow him at x.com/jd_cashless.
