(Headline USA) Standing alone in center field of an empty Dodger Stadium, California Gov. Gavin Newsom cast himself as a bold if imperfect leader and his state as on the cusp of a new day.
Officially, it was the annual State of the State address, but the Tuesday night speech also served as the unofficial campaign kickoff for the first-term Democratic governor, who almost certainly will face a recall election later this year fueled by criticism of his handling of the coronavirus pandemic.
It came only a day after petitioners signaled they had reached the threshold needed for the recall.
Newsom’s woes appear to be part of a broader reckoning against blue-state governors, who long masked—both literally and figuratively—their hypocritical policies while bringing their states to the brink of disaster.
Both New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer have found themselves in considerable hot water, under threat of impeachment and possible criminal probe due to their decision to require nursing homes to accept infected coronavirus patients.
Newsom was one of the five Democrat governors who embraced the policy—the others being Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf and New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy.
All five states were some of the hardest hit in the early days of the pandemic, likely allowing the spread to take root despite then-President Donald Trump’s effort to contain it by restricting entry from China and other countries.
California’s numbers continue to be abysmal relative to other large states, like Florida and Texas, which eschewed the draconian, economy-wrecking lockdowns that Newsom implemented.
On Tuesday, Newsom shed his typical long-windedness and sometimes hard-to-understand jargon for a crisp, 28-minute speech that he scheduled in the evening in Los Angeles to try to maximize viewership.
He’s prone to heavy use of numbers and statistics, but this time stayed above the surface, talking about the future of the nation’s most populated state in broad, optimistic terms.
The governor “led all framing and tweaking and finalized the speech himself,” while the writing team was led by Jason Elliott, a senior counselor to Newsom with a focus on housing and homelessness, said Sahar Roberston, Newsom’s senior communications adviser.
Though Newsom gave only passing reference to the campaign against him, he did so in the most explicit terms yet, defiantly referring to organizers as “promoting partisan political power grabs with outdated prejudices.”
Newsom’s remarks were adopted as anti-recall talking points by politicians from the Asian and Pacific Islander communities in a Wednesday news conference, where they painted the recall as driven by Trump supporters and conspiracy theorists.
“Let’s call this recall what it is: a partisan political power grab,” said Democratic Assemblyman David Chiu of San Francisco.
Recall organizers say they have collected nearly 2 million signatures, well above the 1.5 million needed by March 17 to force an election.
The GOP has only 24% of registered California voters, but organizers say they are attracting Democrats and independents.
“There are a lot of Democrats who are frustrated,” Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon conceded after Newsom’s speech.
But Rendon, a Democrat who sometimes is at odds with Newsom, said the governor deserves credit, not condemnation, for a smart and measured response to the pandemic.
Critics say Newsom has been too restrictive during the health crisis, shuttering businesses and limiting people’s activities far longer than necessary. They also say he has not followed his own directives, notably when he attended a lobbyist’s birthday party at the fancy French Laundry restaurant last fall as he was telling Californians to stay home.
Newsom acknowledged “mistakes” Tuesday but left out specifics, saying only that “we own them, we learn from them, and we never stop trying.”
Republicans blasted the speech as overtly political.
“Gavin’s State of the State address was nothing more than a desperate campaign commercial, paid for by taxpayers, that attempts to explain away a level of incompetence no other governor in California history has reached,” Jessica Millan Patterson, chairwoman of the California Republican Party, said in a statement.
Mindy Romero, founder and director of the left-wing Center for Inclusive Democracy at the University of Southern California, said the campaign undertones were clear, particularly in Newsom’s choice of venue.
Normally, the State of the State is delivered to a joint session of the Legislature from the Capitol in Sacramento.
The usual packed room was impossible with coronavirus restrictions, and rather than speaking to an empty legislative chamber, Newsom chose an empty baseball stadium in the state’s largest city.
The atypical setting took away from the typically formal nature of the State of the State.
“Instead it feels like, ‘My governor is in campaign mode, at a campaign rally, telling me what he wants me to know as he’s facing a recall election,'” she said.
Newsom chose Dodger Stadium because it holds about 56,000 people, nearly the number of Californians who have died from the coronavirus.
It’s also served as a mass testing and vaccination site during the pandemic’s darkest days but is slated to welcome back baseball fans—with crowd limits—next month, a move emblematic of the cautious optimism over improving conditions in California.
Coronavirus numbers nationwide began plummeting the week before President Joe Biden took office, prompting several Republican-led states to announce their full reopening recently.
Newsom’s selection of the unconventional setting garnered mixed reviews.
“It was dripping of so much sugary symbolism,” said Mike Trujillo, a Los Angeles-based Democratic strategist who worked for one of Newsom’s opponents in the 2018 governor’s race. “It didn’t come off the same way as it does in the state Capitol.”
Newsom and his team appeared to take some pointers from other major political events held during the pandemic, like last summer’s virtual Democratic National Convention and January’s inauguration of President Joe Biden.
Two large screens were on either side of Newsom during the speech with faces of his supporters on a Zoom call, silently clapping and cheering as he spoke.
Rob Stutzman, who was spokesman for former Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, said Newsom’s team deserves credit for trying something new.
“At the end of the day, it was probably an attempt to do too much, but nothing that’s damaging,” said Stutzman, whose former boss came to power after a recall election and whose governorship was marked by celebrity and spectacle.
Newsom, for his part, kept up the positive, forward-looking messaging Wednesday as he remained in Los Angeles to visit a vaccination site.
“We are going to come back. We’re not going to come crawling back. We’re going to roar back. This state is poised for an incredible recovery,” he told reporters. “I have incredible optimism about the future.”
Adapted from reporting by the Associated Press
